There are a lot of different prospect ranking sites out there. Now that Keith Law has come out with his Red Sox prospects list, I took a look at that and some other lists to see if there was any consensus on who our top prospects are.
Law writes for the Athletic now, so his new Sox top prospects list is behind their paywall:
https://theathletic.com/1609934/2020/02/26/keith-laws-guide-to-top-red-sox-prospects/?source=dailyemail
Keith Law top 10:
1. Downs
2. Casas
3. Song
4. Groome
5. Duran
6. Ward
7. Dalbec
8. Jimenez
9. Mata
10. Houck
Fangraphs has a list from December 2019, but it was updated after the trade where we got J.D. Downs and Wong:
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/top-33-prospects-boston-red-sox/
1. Downs
2. Casas
3. Mata
4. Dalbec
5. Song
6. Jimenez
7. Lugo
8. Cannon
9. Houck
10. Duran
MLB.com:
http://m.mlb.com/prospects/2019?list=bos
1. Casas
2. Downs
3. Dalbec
4. Mata
5. Duran
6. Houck
7. Groome
8. Jimenez
9. Ward
10. Chatham
Prospects1500.com, whatever that is:
https://www.prospects1500.com/al-east/red-sox/boston-red-sox-2020-top-50-prospects/
1. Casas
2. Downs
3. Dalbec
4. Jimenez
5. Mata
6. Groome
7. Duran
8. Ward
9. Houck
10. Chatham
Sox prospects:
https://www.soxprospects.com/
1. Casas
2. Downs
3. Mata
4. Groome
5. Jimenez
6. Dalbec
7. Duran
8. Houck
9. Song
10. Chatham
Here's a consensus from these 5 sources:
Consensus Points (10 points for a top ranking, 9 for #2, etc.):
1. Casas: 48
2. Downs: 47
3. Dalbec: 32
4. Mata: 31
5. Jimenez: 24
6. Groome: 23
7. Duran: 21
8. Song: 16
9. Houck: 13
10. Ward: 10
11. Lugo: 4
12. Cannon: 3
13. Chatham: 3
#1 or #2 in all 5 lists:
Casas and Downs
In the Top 10 on all 5 lists:
Downs, Casas, Duran, Dalbec, Jiminez, Mata, and Houck
Law writes for the Athletic now, so his new Sox top prospects list is behind their paywall:
https://theathletic.com/1609934/2020/02/26/keith-laws-guide-to-top-red-sox-prospects/?source=dailyemail
Keith Law top 10:
1. Downs
2. Casas
3. Song
4. Groome
5. Duran
6. Ward
7. Dalbec
8. Jimenez
9. Mata
10. Houck
Fangraphs has a list from December 2019, but it was updated after the trade where we got J.D. Downs and Wong:
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/top-33-prospects-boston-red-sox/
1. Downs
2. Casas
3. Mata
4. Dalbec
5. Song
6. Jimenez
7. Lugo
8. Cannon
9. Houck
10. Duran
MLB.com:
http://m.mlb.com/prospects/2019?list=bos
1. Casas
2. Downs
3. Dalbec
4. Mata
5. Duran
6. Houck
7. Groome
8. Jimenez
9. Ward
10. Chatham
Prospects1500.com, whatever that is:
https://www.prospects1500.com/al-east/red-sox/boston-red-sox-2020-top-50-prospects/
1. Casas
2. Downs
3. Dalbec
4. Jimenez
5. Mata
6. Groome
7. Duran
8. Ward
9. Houck
10. Chatham
Sox prospects:
https://www.soxprospects.com/
1. Casas
2. Downs
3. Mata
4. Groome
5. Jimenez
6. Dalbec
7. Duran
8. Houck
9. Song
10. Chatham
Here's a consensus from these 5 sources:
Consensus Points (10 points for a top ranking, 9 for #2, etc.):
1. Casas: 48
2. Downs: 47
3. Dalbec: 32
4. Mata: 31
5. Jimenez: 24
6. Groome: 23
7. Duran: 21
8. Song: 16
9. Houck: 13
10. Ward: 10
11. Lugo: 4
12. Cannon: 3
13. Chatham: 3
#1 or #2 in all 5 lists:
Casas and Downs
In the Top 10 on all 5 lists:
Downs, Casas, Duran, Dalbec, Jiminez, Mata, and Houck