The Adventures of Malik Cunningham

JokersWildJIMED

Blinded by Borges
SoSH Member
Oct 7, 2004
2,754
Disagree, Malik is a WR
Probably true, but based on what he showed in preseason as a WR, he looked absolutely lost. Hard to believe he went from that to a 3 year contract as a wideout…hope here is that it’s more as a QB.
 

Eddie Jurak

canderson-lite
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2002
44,965
Melrose, MA
This seems weird - I wonder if a team was trying to sign Malik.

They are thin at WR at the moment with Douglas and Juju out, so he coukld help there, but they could just elevate him of this were strictly about short term depth.

I think he's here as a WR but also they want to put in a package of plays he can run as QB.\

View: https://twitter.com/AlbertBreer/status/1713284292762112411?s=20

Albert Breer: New England had packages for Malik Cunningham at both quarterback and receiver in practice this week. So they could get creative in how they use him vs. Vegas.

Yep. Mac is going to start but Cunningham will get some snaps.
 

DeJesus Built My Hotrod

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 24, 2002
49,041
I don't care if they see him as a WR, QB1 or their starting LT. This team needs to do something different. I don't know if this counts as that but why not?
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,160
Probably true, but based on what he showed in preseason as a WR, he looked absolutely lost. Hard to believe he went from that to a 3 year contract as a wideout…hope here is that it’s more as a QB.
3 year deal with basically no guarantees is what UDFA usually get. If he develops team gets him for 3 years cheap, if he doesn't they can cut him at any point for no future money
 

snowmanny

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
15,840
Somebody adept at running away from people seems like a good short-term choice for Patriots QB.
 

Eck'sSneakyCheese

Member
SoSH Member
May 11, 2011
10,479
NH
This needs to happen. His running ability is next level. He might actually be able to escape the quickly disappearing pocket our o line produces. RPO and play action for days. The team will rally around this kid. Hell, all of New England will rally around this kid. It’s a glimmer of hope.
 

koufax32

He'll cry if he wants to...
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2006
9,138
Duval
Is he going to be used like the Pittsburgh version of Antwaan Randel-El here?

The three year deal doesn’t say desperation. It says they are confident in his progression. I’m intrigued. If he starts to get snaps at least there will be a reason to watch now.

Edit: Goid points above about the probability of no contractual guarantees going forward.
 

IdiotKicker

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 21, 2005
11,083
Somerville, MA
This is worth reading. BB said more than he normally does.

Others have noted BB’s praise for Cunningham’s improvement as a receiver. He also described him as “competent” as a QB, which I took as a sign that BB considers him an option if Mac continues to flounder.
I like when BB gets all “items a little too early for an induction ceremony” when he talks. I feel like when BB minimizes how good someone on the team is, it means he thinks he has something there.
 

CoffeeNerdness

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 6, 2012
8,937
My heart says yes, but head says these are the minds that brought us Mac Jones, Nelson Agholor, Mohammed Sanu, N'Keal Harry, and Bailey Zappe.
 

nattysez

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 30, 2010
8,582
If BB weren't also the GM, I'd say this move was a message to the FO about how unsalvageable Mac is. As things are, this move suggests that BB is out of ideas for improving the offense.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,160
If BB weren't also the GM, I'd say this move was a message to the FO about how unsalvageable Mac is. As things are, this move suggests that BB is out of ideas for improving the offense.
Or.... they like the player they have an open roster spot, why not sign him and see what he can do as a WR and gadget guy

He's not being signed to play QB full-time, they made that really clear many, many times
 

DennyDoyle'sBoil

Found no thrill on Blueberry Hill
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2008
43,431
AZ
3 year deal with basically no guarantees is what UDFA usually get. If he develops team gets him for 3 years cheap, if he doesn't they can cut him at any point for no future money
Yeah, Miguel speculates this is just a 2+ year UDFa deal for the minimum, which he estimates as 2023 $750k prorated, 2024 915k, 2025 1.03m. Just avoiding going through the ERFA process each year. Not sure when Miguel will update but Pats are now really low on cap space for the rest of the year. Maybe $2m? Any new player will be at least $750k pro-rated, and practice squad elevations will be tens of thousands in any week they do it.
 

Shaky Walton

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 20, 2019
739
If the Pats are losing big, or Mac is playing horribly tomorrow, why NOT give him a look? Zappe is never going to be the answer.
 

Traut

lost his degree
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2005
12,799
My Desk
If the Pats are losing big, or Mac is playing horribly tomorrow, why NOT give him a look? Zappe is never going to be the answer.
Nothing is wasted if you learn. The Patriots have learned this season that Bailey Zappe is not the guy. Hell, he probably isn't even just another guy.

Mac Jones almost certainly isn't the guy.

With nothing to lose it's time to learn what they have in Cunningham.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,160
The idea that you just throw in a guy who didn't get drafted as a QB, nobody else wanted to sign as a QB, and has been practicing primarily as a WR to...... see what you have is just silly. That's not how teams run, you're more likely to see Grier active and thrown in if Mac struggles.

Playing Mac is what you have to do, he's clearly the best QB on the roster, he was in pre-season, he was an ok QB for 2 full seasons (not good, but clearly an NFL QB), you can't have a culture based around hard work and accountability if the coaches are throwing in CUnningham as anything other than a gimmick guy, that's contrary to everything a good organization does.
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,171
I can’t wait for everyone to lose their mind when he’s inactive tomorrow.
Yup, I wouldn't mind seeing the kid get a look, especially at WR, because at least he has some NFL skills with the ball in his hands, but BB could just as likely be trying to play head games with Josh, and trying to make him spend time preparing for something that might not happen.
 

Salva135

Cassandra
Oct 19, 2008
1,572
Boston
The idea that you just throw in a guy who didn't get drafted as a QB, nobody else wanted to sign as a QB, and has been practicing primarily as a WR to...... see what you have is just silly. That's not how teams run, you're more likely to see Grier active and thrown in if Mac struggles.

Playing Mac is what you have to do, he's clearly the best QB on the roster, he was in pre-season, he was an ok QB for 2 full seasons (not good, but clearly an NFL QB), you can't have a culture based around hard work and accountability if the coaches are throwing in CUnningham as anything other than a gimmick guy, that's contrary to everything a good organization does.
Well, the good news is this is not at all a good organization right now, so they're more than welcome to try whatever they can.
 

DennyDoyle'sBoil

Found no thrill on Blueberry Hill
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2008
43,431
AZ
The idea that you just throw in a guy who didn't get drafted as a QB, nobody else wanted to sign as a QB, and has been practicing primarily as a WR to...... see what you have is just silly. That's not how teams run, you're more likely to see Grier active and thrown in if Mac struggles.

Playing Mac is what you have to do, he's clearly the best QB on the roster, he was in pre-season, he was an ok QB for 2 full seasons (not good, but clearly an NFL QB), you can't have a culture based around hard work and accountability if the coaches are throwing in CUnningham as anything other than a gimmick guy, that's contrary to everything a good organization does.
Yeah, and on the small chance Malik May some day be a good NFL QB, throwing him into the fire could screw him up.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,160
Well, the good news is this is not at all a good organization right now, so they're more than welcome to try whatever they can.
It's a bad team, it's a well run organization.

I get that people forget because we had the greatest 2 decade run in the history of American sports basically, but a couple .500ish seasons and what looks like it's going to be a bad year is.... pretty standard, and it always looks ugly. Every team has a stretch where the drafts and FA signings have too many misses, every team has the occasional brain drain issue.
 

Harry Hooper

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jan 4, 2002
34,641
Yeah, Miguel speculates this is just a 2+ year UDFa deal for the minimum, which he estimates as 2023 $750k prorated, 2024 915k, 2025 1.03m. Just avoiding going through the ERFA process each year. Not sure when Miguel will update but Pats are now really low on cap space for the rest of the year. Maybe $2m? Any new player will be at least $750k pro-rated, and practice squad elevations will be tens of thousands in any week they do it.
Wouldn't practice squad guys have salaries too low to figure into any cap calculations?
 

Salva135

Cassandra
Oct 19, 2008
1,572
Boston
It's a bad team, it's a well run organization.

I get that people forget because we had the greatest 2 decade run in the history of American sports basically, but a couple .500ish seasons and what looks like it's going to be a bad year is.... pretty standard, and it always looks ugly. Every team has a stretch where the drafts and FA signings have too many misses, every team has the occasional brain drain issue.
I've seen a number of your posts throughout this board lately to this effect, and while I understand your thought process, I don't think you're grasping just how bad and deep this problem is. There is nothing standard about how bad this team is right now, it's fundamentally poor of talent.
 
Last edited:

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,160
I've seen a number of your posts throughout this board lately to this effect, and while I understand your thought process, I don't think you're grasping just how bad and deep this problem is. There is nothing standard about how bad this team is right now, it's fundamentally poor of talent.
I grasp it quite well... this team is bad. It's not any worse than some of the other bad teams both this and previous years. It's also probably better positioned than most to fix it should they get a high pick. People acting like this team is so devoid of talent that it's unprecedented are just being hysterical. They're lacking WR talent and they don't have a QB. The defense has a lot of talent, and they are set up to have a ton of cap space int he summer.

Go take a look at last year's Bears (or Texans), take a look at the Cardinals' roster this year, the 2021 Jags (and 2020) the 2020 Jets... this team blows away those teams in terms of talent on the roster and cap flexibility.

Now there is some reason to wonder if you trust the current guy in charge to use the picks/cap space effectively, but the actual situation is pretty normal... team loses star QB, top talent ages out slowly, they miss on FA signings and draft picks, then the bottom falls out and they have to hard re-set. Part of it is because they tried to do a hard reset in 2020 and 2021 and whiffed.

The Patriots will go into the offseason with a lot of holes, but a lot of ways to fill them, and not many bad deals on the books (Just Juju really), they have quite a bit of talent locked up on D, and on O they have some depth pieces. They probably won't be good next year either (though not impossible with the right moves and some luck), but they should be well on their way to a quick turnaround if they handle the offseason well..... whether they will is the question.
 

Salva135

Cassandra
Oct 19, 2008
1,572
Boston
I grasp it quite well... this team is bad. It's not any worse than some of the other bad teams both this and previous years. It's also probably better positioned than most to fix it should they get a high pick. People acting like this team is so devoid of talent that it's unprecedented are just being hysterical. They're lacking WR talent and they don't have a QB. The defense has a lot of talent, and they are set up to have a ton of cap space int he summer.

Go take a look at last year's Bears (or Texans), take a look at the Cardinals' roster this year, the 2021 Jags (and 2020) the 2020 Jets... this team blows away those teams in terms of talent on the roster and cap flexibility.

Now there is some reason to wonder if you trust the current guy in charge to use the picks/cap space effectively, but the actual situation is pretty normal... team loses star QB, top talent ages out slowly, they miss on FA signings and draft picks, then the bottom falls out and they have to hard re-set. Part of it is because they tried to do a hard reset in 2020 and 2021 and whiffed.

The Patriots will go into the offseason with a lot of holes, but a lot of ways to fill them, and not many bad deals on the books (Just Juju really), they have quite a bit of talent locked up on D, and on O they have some depth pieces. They probably won't be good next year either (though not impossible with the right moves and some luck), but they should be well on their way to a quick turnaround if they handle the offseason well..... whether they will is the question.
JFC what are you looking at or smoking to come to these conclusions?

You had me at "the Patriots will go into the offseason with a lot of holes"

I get it. You're one of the last people who thinks BB has tricks up his sleeve. There are a few posters left on here like that. They propose these fantastical ideas where BB runs the defense and someone else scores touchdowns. It's sad. They can't adapt any more than him.
 
Last edited:

GPO Man

New Member
Apr 1, 2023
571
Yup, I wouldn't mind seeing the kid get a look, especially at WR, because at least he has some NFL skills with the ball in his hands, but BB could just as likely be trying to play head games with Josh, and trying to make him spend time preparing for something that might not happen.
I’m sure McDaniels is shaking in his boots with the prospect of facing Malik Cunningham and the vaunted Patriots offense.
 

NDame616

will bailey
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2006
2,378
It'll be interesting to see if he's active today. I still expect today Grier to be the QB2. I think Bill and BoB have all seen enough to know Zappe isn't the backup.
 

Salva135

Cassandra
Oct 19, 2008
1,572
Boston
I think they'll try some packages if the situation opens itself for it.

It's sad we're at this point, but if BB is going to show he's the GOAT, he needs to try and make plays. This team is next to dead.
 

Over Guapo Grande

panty merchant
SoSH Member
Nov 29, 2005
4,552
Worcester
It'll be interesting to see if he's active today. I still expect today Grier to be the QB2. I think Bill and BoB have all seen enough to know Zappe isn't the backup.
I think he almost has to be- on Friday they had downgraded 7 people to out. So with the PS elevations, that leaves them at what… 49 for the 46+EQB game day roster?
 

Eddie Jurak

canderson-lite
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2002
44,965
Melrose, MA
I think he almost has to be- on Friday they had downgraded 7 people to out. So with the PS elevations, that leaves them at what… 49 for the 46+EQB game day roster?
Of the seven people they downgraded to out, one was Matt Judon who has since been put on IR, one is Cody Davis who is still working his way back from PUP and not on the active roster, and one is Tyrone Wheatley who was also put on IR.

The Pats elevated Pharms (DT) and Reagor (WR) from the practice squad, signed Malik Cunningham (WR/QB), activated Tyquan Thornton.

Out for sure are Smith-Schuster, Douglas, Strange, and Reiff (the other 4 who had been downgraded).

Grier will likely be scratched and designated QB3.

Two others will need to be scratched. Since they now have 6 WR on the 53 or elevated (Parker, Bourne, Boutte, Thornton, Cunningham, Reagor) it seems likely that one of those could be scratched. Seems unlikely that Thornton, Cunningham, or Reagor would be scratched, since they all could have been left where they were for another week. Maybe Boutte?

That would leave one more slot.
 

cornwalls@6

Less observant than others
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
6,325
from the wilds of western ma
JFC what are you looking at or smoking to come to these conclusions?

You had me at "the Patriots will go into the offseason with a lot of holes"

I get it. You're one of the last people who thinks BB has tricks up his sleeve. There are a few posters left on here like that. They propose these fantastical ideas where BB runs the defense and someone else scores touchdowns. It's sad. They can't adapt any more than him.
You are a cartoonishly bad poster on this topic. Beating the same petulant, entitled , tiresome drum ad nauseam, in multiple threads. Your inability or unwillingness to accept the inevitable down cycle that teams have after a long run of success, without devolving into talk radio level noise about how “bad” the organization , and BB, supposedly are, reveals you to be the one not dealing in reality. It may be time to move on from Bill. Everything ends eventually. That’s a legit debate that can be had without your level of reactionary foolishness.