Celtics vs Da Culture - Round 1 (FIGHT!)

Eric Fernsten's Disco Mustache

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Since we're all putting out Bam comps, I'll add one more for those who remember the Charlotte Hornet teams of the mid-90s

Bam is a more consistently competitive, better defensive version of Larry Johnson (GrandMama) without the lower back injury

At 6'8"-6'9" both are/were surprisingly strong and powerful for basically having the frame and length of big wings. Neither guy played above the rim, so much as they used their power and explosiveness to get up to it around/through longer/taller players. Neither guy developed a ton of moves for scoring in and around the paint, counting on other guys (Muggsy Bogues, Jimmy Butler, Goran Dragic) to set the table for them. Both were/are surprisingly good passers for big men (although not the level of Sabonis). Grandmama got bored on defense more than Bam, some of which might be the whole Heat culture thing. And Johnson was much more into being the center of attention, when he could.

Beyond that, a bunch of the differences in their games is mostly a result of playing in very different eras. If you brought the version of GrandMama who came out of UNLV into today's game lots of teams would play him as a small ball 5 surrounded by shooters. He'd probably develop an outside game himself. As it was he played most of his minutes next to Alonzo Mourning, in what today would be a floor-spacing nightmare...



Edit/update:

Not trying to start anything, but I think some of the other comps are much further off from the way Bam plays offense, defense, or both
  • KG & Bosh were mostly mid-post offensive shooters, who had the most impact as defenders off-the-ball and in rotation. Bam scores going to the basket and plays some of his best defense muscling the person with the ball. And, I mean, when it came to defensive intensity KG was in another world from most humans on the planet.
  • Dwight Howard and AD are so much bigger that the way they affect the game (especially with rebounding and controlling the paint) was very different
  • Faried's the right size and frame, although Bam has something like 20-25 pounds on him. Faried's always been a mediocre defender + great rebounder, whereas Bam is something closer to the reverse.
Early Horford is not a bad comp. Bam doesn't have the same ball skills or self-creation in the paint that young Al did. And Horford was closer to league-average on defense instead of being a perennial All Defensive Team candidate. But that's a good ballpark.
 
Last edited:

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,551
I think of Bam comps less as the physical comps than the impact comps - he's relatively similar in overall impact and offense/defense split to Gobert (great defender, contributes offensively but in a limited way) even though the componets are different at each end (he's more switchable and less an alpha rim protector defensively; he's a much better passer with more range, but less a rim runner and offensive rebounder on offensive end).

He's also similar, as noted, to Sabonis in overall value though the offense/defense ratio of that value is pretty different.

For older timers: Both physically and in terms of impact, there's some Wes Unseld (who was a better rebounder) and some Dave Cowens (better offensively) in there too
 

Eric Fernsten's Disco Mustache

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Welcome Back old friend!
Back 'atchya!


I think of Bam comps less as the physical comps than the impact comps
That's an interesting way to think about it. It obviously takes you in a different direction than where I was going.

For older timers: Both physically and in terms of impact, there's some Wes Unseld (who was a better rebounder) and some Dave Cowens (better offensively) in there too
Now we're going way back...
 
Last edited:

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,448
I always thought Bam and Siakam were similar.

As I noted in the game thread I thought the Heat got really aggressive in extending their defense in their 4th quarter run and jumped the first swing pass. Tatum went from handling it all easily to a turnover machine for a bit there. Don’t think Miami can do that enough to do much with it but it would be nice to see an adjustment as I’m sure the other future opponents will be watching. Ideally you’d just dribble drive some of these situations because there’s very little congestion when they overplay like this but Tatum dribbles himself into trouble that way a decent amount. Porzingis at the free throw line should relieve a lot of that but for whatever reason we only have the discipline to run that way for like the first 6 minutes of a basketball game then it’s all pick and pop from then on out
Denver does the same thing in jumping the swing pass, so it's important to prepare for. As you said, Tatum handled it easily early on, and I think that in the 4th it was just boredom/laziness, which affected the whole team.

Joe left the starters in up 18 with 1 minute left, so I think he wanted to force them to stay out there and finish it out/work through stuff, because that start to the 4th was pretty lazy and unacceptable.
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,495
Santa Monica
This discussion takes the cake in terms of widest spectrum of possible comps. We've now compared Bam to Xavier Tillman and Kenneth Faried, on the one hand, and Anthony Davis and Kevin Garnett on the other!

My two cents - any comp for Bam has to take into account that what makes him such a valuable player is his defense. He's not a great offensive player, but he's athletic and can finish a bit around the rim. I think his passing is underrated in this discussion. The Heat have historically been much better when Bam is aggressive in trying to score. I think he's Draymond with a better offensive game inside of 15 feet, and less of a defensive savant. But that's the model, the rare big who can protect the rim and switch on the perimeter. Young Horford was similar.
Miami would be better off trading Bam for a skilled WING & adding Tillman on the cheap in FA

That's why any of those lists that have Bam or Gobert ranked ahead of Jaylen Brown are laughable.
 

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,551
I also think conditioning is a reason to leave them out there---more than any other team or any recent season, the starters have not gone 40+ hard minutes at all often in the last six weeks so helping build the legs back up seems wise to me - they had plenty of rest over the last month
 

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,448
I also think conditioning is a reason to leave them out there---more than any other team or any recent season, the starters have not gone 40+ hard minutes at all often in the last six weeks so helping build the legs back up seems wise to me - they had plenty of rest over the last month
And another 2 days off before Game 2.
 

Eric Fernsten's Disco Mustache

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
As I noted in the game thread I thought the Heat got really aggressive in extending their defense in their 4th quarter run and jumped the first swing pass. Tatum went from handling it all easily to a turnover machine for a bit there. Don’t think Miami can do that enough to do much with it but it would be nice to see an adjustment as I’m sure the other future opponents will be watching
It's a good flag

I have to re-watch those plays, but another classic way you break down this defense is with a more movement off the ball.

When the ball-handler (Tatum) is doubled really high, and then two defenders are playing tight in the passing lanes to his first target on both sides, that leaves one final defender in effect playing 1-on-2 against the guys in the corners. If the rest of the Celtics stand around that leaves Tatum with the bad option of trying to dribble through a double-team (with nobody behind him to protect the rim if he turns it over), or trying to pass through the guys in the passing lanes. Instead, of the other four Celtics see this coverage and respond with some back-screens, and get someone cutting into space, it gives Tatum a much easier target, potentially with a clear lane to the hoop
 

Jimbodandy

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 31, 2006
11,627
around the way
Good post. IIRC, they ran some kind of zone full-court press in the first half for a few series. But, yes, they'll have to try something more aggressive, maybe man trapping. Pritchard seems like a good counter-move to this, potentially, as he plays super fast energy and a good handle (although his height could be a liability against traps). I imagine it's hard to maintain this defense for Miami, though, when you barely have 7-8 real NBA players to throw out there.

One thing I didn't love from C's offensive perspective: they started out getting a lot of looks at the hoop with Tatum and Brown, sometimes kicking it out for great looks from 3, helping them build the early 15 point lead. Brown bungled a few opportunities with shaky ball-handling, but it was there early. I don't know if Miami made an adjustment, but from the 2nd quarter on, it turned more into Circus of Three Pointers, which we hit enough of to do fine, but I wondered what happened to the early close-mid-range looks. Tatum hit a few foul-line post-ups... KP as well.. I don't remember seeing one single JB mid-range fade-away (the thing where he dribbles in, then turns and shoots a foul-line jumper over a helpless Duncan Robinson)... in general it seemed we spent a lot less time near the hoop after the opening quarter.

I hope to see G2 emphasis on getting close-mid-range looks for JB and others. Horford, for one, had the opportunity to get bunnies at the basket all day when the C's went 2bigs (he posted once or twice, and it looked like light work). Miami just doesn't have another big body besides Bam to throw at anyone.
I think part of this was the defense, Miami playing to take the drive away and (thus) concede the three. I think if you were Miami you had to be pretty happy with coming out of the first quarter down only 5, but clearly, what they were doing did not hold up.

My concern, not an issue yesterday, is that when Miami clogs the paint and allows the three, it is important for the Celtics to still work on generating quality looks and not just jacking up the first available shot. I also want to see JB, when mobbed on drives, recognize it and pull up or move the ball. That's an ever-improving part of his game that will be crucial in the playoffs. (JB and JT were good yesterday at passing out of double teams and they need to keep it up.)
Good criticism and good response.

In game 1, Miami clearly was collapsing bigtime on drives. It got us a lot of open 3 looks. It wouldn't be a huge surprise if Spoel rearranges some deck chairs. But honestly I don't think that he has an answer. There isn't one.

We love our dunks, but we'll take good open 3 looks any day.
 

joe dokes

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
30,680
I have to re-watch those plays, but another classic way you break down this defense is with a more movement off the ball.

When the ball-handler (Tatum) is doubled really high, and then two defenders are playing tight in the passing lanes to his first target on both sides, that leaves one final defender in effect playing 1-on-2 against the guys in the corners. If the rest of the Celtics stand around that leaves Tatum with the bad option of trying to dribble through a double-team (with nobody behind him to protect the rim if he turns it over), or trying to pass through the guys in the passing lanes. Instead, of the other four Celtics see this coverage and respond with some back-screens, and get someone cutting into space, it gives Tatum a much easier target, potentially with a clear lane to the hoop
Related to responding to traps....There was one play (I wish I could recall when) where Tatum had the ball in front of the left hashmark, got doubled and was *about* to pass to the middle - right as the defense rotated to that spot to jump the pass. And *just* as the defender moved, he whipped it way across court for an open 3. I remember a couple of those where you could see the wheels turning -- trap---defend anticipated pass--fake that pass to get defenders moving--pass to now open guy way over on weak side.
In real time, I thought that the Miami defenders were jumping the pass too soon and the Celtics were getting lucky.. Maybe it was the Celtics remembering the film sessions.
 

NomarsFool

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2001
8,307
Where does Miami find points? Boston blanketed Herro, and played very aggressively through Bam screens. Miami has to get extremely hot from three to stay with the Celtics.
During the game, I was wondering whether the Celtics should just start doubling Bam as he was the only one who could score (this was early in the game). But, at the same time, they were also still torching the Heat. So, I think it's a bit hard to switch up your defense when, generally, what you are doing is working.
 

koufax32

He'll cry if he wants to...
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2006
9,132
Duval
One thing I’d like to see is someone do to Bam what Kobe did to Pau Gasol in the Olympics. You want to set a hard screen that doesn’t get called? Okay. Maybe Tilman can come in and just truck him. Bonus points if he yells “BAM!” while doing it. The only way MIA can win is if they muck it up like a hopelessly outmatched hockey team in the SCP’s. Maybe someone can send a message during the first quarter Wednesday like Brown tossing Robinson.
 

RorschachsMask

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 23, 2011
5,437
Lynn
One thing I’d like to see is someone do to Bam what Kobe did to Pau Gasol in the Olympics. You want to set a hard screen that doesn’t get called? Okay. Maybe Tilman can come in and just truck him. Bonus points if he yells “BAM!” while doing it. The only way MIA can win is if they muck it up like a hopelessly outmatched hockey team in the SCP’s. Maybe someone can send a message during the first quarter Wednesday like Brown tossing Robinson.
Tatum did it yesterday, IIRC. Not sure if it was a true truck, but Bam ended up on the ground.
 

Eric Fernsten's Disco Mustache

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
During the game, I was wondering whether the Celtics should just start doubling Bam as he was the only one who could score

I'm guessing the logic of the coaching staff [note: not endorsing this, just typing up why I think they're doing what they're doing] is that the best offensive players on the Miami roster are used to scoring off ball movement because someone else has done things that got them open. But none of them are great at creating looks for themselves.

So, if you double Bam (a good passer) and ball movement gets someone an open shot, that shooter is going to be doing something he's used to and good at. But if you have all your defenders stay home, and force everyone on the Heat to create their own looks, then whatever happens whoever's doing it is probably uncomfortable and outta their element.
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,495
Santa Monica
Unless that skilled wing is a top 20 player in the NBA this is nonsense. I know we all love Xavier Tillman and hate anything Heat but come on now.
I don't hate Bam, but definitely don't think he is a TOP20-30 NBA player.
IMO defense-first Centers, that run around screening on offense are a great place to find value in the NBA

Question, would you swap KP for Bam for these playoffs?
 

RorschachsMask

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 23, 2011
5,437
Lynn
During the game, I was wondering whether the Celtics should just start doubling Bam as he was the only one who could score (this was early in the game). But, at the same time, they were also still torching the Heat. So, I think it's a bit hard to switch up your defense when, generally, what you are doing is working.
If Bam wants to score 20-30 points on tough shots against single coverage, the Celtics won’t even bat an eye.

How players get defended is more important than a couple of extra made or missed shots.
 

m0ckduck

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2005
1,802
If Bam wants to score 20-30 points on tough shots against single coverage, the Celtics won’t even bat an eye.

How players get defended is more important than a couple of extra made or missed shots.
Agreed. But Miami must be at least thinking about trying to force-feed him in G2 under the rationale that (1) it was their best offensive matchup AND (2) they have the chance to get KP in foul trouble and off the court. That's potentially a huge win-win for them.
 

RorschachsMask

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 23, 2011
5,437
Lynn
Agreed. But Miami must be at least thinking about trying to force-feed him in G2 under the rationale that (1) it was their best offensive matchup AND (2) they have the chance to get KP in foul trouble and off the court. That's potentially a huge win-win for them.
I agree, they have to try it. But the Celtics won’t care, and won’t change the way they defend him.

It plays into why I didn’t think Miami had any shot. They don’t have the offense, and the Celtics are way too big on the other end.
 

wade boggs chicken dinner

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 26, 2005
30,935
the other four Celtics see this coverage and respond with some back-screens, and get someone cutting into space, it gives Tatum a much easier target, potentially with a clear lane to the hoop
Or JT can throw it up to the 7'3" guy and let him (and the other guys) play 4 on 3 or 3 on 2.

I suppose they have numbers on this but it seems to me that doubling JT out high is leading to a lot of points. If I were an opposing coach, I wouldn't do it except maybe once or twice a game as a change-up.
 

Eric Fernsten's Disco Mustache

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
I suppose they have numbers on this but it seems to me that doubling JT out high is leading to a lot of points. If I were an opposing coach, I wouldn't do it except maybe once or twice a game as a change-up.
Sure

I mean, that was kinda what Spro did at the start of the 4th, in the stretch that everyone has been gnashing their teeth about. Then later Boston started breaking the trap, and Miami stopped trying it
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,504
I hope everyone got to see the other angle of the Tatum/Martin play that showed Jrue shoving Martin into Tatum. Zero percent chance there was anything intentional or dirty about the play. Not sure what Jrue was doing/thinking though.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
11,944
Adrenaline is a helluva a drug. Crazy that he almost got them to pull out a win against Philly.
Not sure how much he had to do with them almost winning.. and not sure when he got hurt.. but he had 9 points in the second half and 2 in the fourth.. His teammates tried to pick up the slack as he looked pretty hobbled.. at times he looked like more of a decoy in the corner.
 

DavidTai

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 18, 2003
1,262
Herndon, VA
Sure

I mean, that was kinda what Spro did at the start of the 4th, in the stretch that everyone has been gnashing their teeth about. Then later Boston started breaking the trap, and Miami stopped trying it
I mean, I think that normally wouldn't get too much attention, but throw in Wright suddenly turning into a flamethrower in that run, and Negative Man of the Doom Patrol would turn that into some imagined test of mental fortitude (which practically every playoff team would fail by those standards!)
 

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,551
I hope everyone got to see the other angle of the Tatum/Martin play that showed Jrue shoving Martin into Tatum. Zero percent chance there was anything intentional or dirty about the play. Not sure what Jrue was doing/thinking though.
Yeah, unfortunately for that POV Martin was already low and in full motion. The physics doesn't allow for what you say above---he was already headed for Tatum, and hard, and Jrue can't generate enough force to cause that impact otherwise.

I do agree it's really odd whatever Jrue was doing there, though.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,051
Yeah, unfortunately for that POV Martin was already low and in full motion. The physics doesn't allow for what you say above---he was already headed for Tatum, and hard, and Jrue can't generate enough force to cause that impact otherwise.

I do agree it's really odd whatever Jrue was doing there, though.
He's coming in at speed to make a play, Jrue shoves him in the back which makes it hard for him to jump making him crash low into Tatum (and btw Jrue can generate a whole lot of force)... if he comes in there and jumps it's a nothing play, probably an over the back on the rebound.
 

Jimbodandy

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 31, 2006
11,627
around the way
I don't hate Bam, but definitely don't think he is a TOP20-30 NBA player.
IMO defense-first Centers, that run around screening on offense are a great place to find value in the NBA

Question, would you swap KP for Bam for these playoffs?
I like Bam's game a lot too, but I don't want to live in a world where he's a top 20 player. Salary aside, if he's a top 20 player, the Celtics have like 3 or 4 top 20 players.
 

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,448
I think what Jrue was trying to do was to clear Martin out of space, so that he wouldn't be able to grab a rebound in that area.

It looks pretty clear on replay that Jrue gives Martin a ton of extra force: if a guy already has momentum in a direction, and you push, you really add a lot to it.

I hope everyone got to see the other angle of the Tatum/Martin play that showed Jrue shoving Martin into Tatum. Zero percent chance there was anything intentional or dirty about the play. Not sure what Jrue was doing/thinking though.
People have a lot of confirmation bias re "the dirty Miami Heat", and no amount of evidence will change their minds. Personally, I'm content to just hate them as a fan.
 

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,551
The reason they have that rep is that they do a lot of dirty things, of course.

Why does Martin duck, in your interpretation? That is the dirty part and it clearly has nothing to do with the push (which is directional, not down). That's what you cannot do on any playground in America, go low on a jumping player.

What you guys are saying fits for Martin running into Tatum high. But the evidence actually shows him ducking. That just isn't about Jrue.
 

pjheff

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 4, 2003
1,344
The reason they have that rep is that they do a lot of dirty things, of course.

Why does Martin duck, in your interpretation? That is the dirty part and it clearly has nothing to do with the push (which is directional, not down). That's what you cannot do on any playground in America, go low on a jumping player.

What you guys are saying fits for Martin running into Tatum high. But the evidence actually shows him ducking. That just isn't about Jrue.
Exactly. I’m not saying that Spo called a code red. But Martin appeared to be borrowing from Draymond’s game 2 playbook to try to rattle the Celtics with increased and unpredictable physicality.
 

Bosoxian

New Member
Aug 17, 2021
166
The reason they have that rep is that they do a lot of dirty things, of course.

Why does Martin duck, in your interpretation? That is the dirty part and it clearly has nothing to do with the push (which is directional, not down). That's what you cannot do on any playground in America, go low on a jumping player.

What you guys are saying fits for Martin running into Tatum high. But the evidence actually shows him ducking. That just isn't about Jrue.
This is getting some play in the media. They played the radio calls of both teams and the Miami call was ridiculous. Something along the line of “Tatum slides down Martin’s back.”
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,051
The reason they have that rep is that they do a lot of dirty things, of course.

Why does Martin duck, in your interpretation? That is the dirty part and it clearly has nothing to do with the push (which is directional, not down). That's what you cannot do on any playground in America, go low on a jumping player.

What you guys are saying fits for Martin running into Tatum high. But the evidence actually shows him ducking. That just isn't about Jrue.
Martin doesn't duck, watch the video, he's standing up straight when he colides with Tatum, he only bends over when Tatum comes down on him.

Edit- pretty clearly exactly what you'd expect from a push, he gets sped up and isn't into his jump yet when he collides with Tatum

View: https://twitter.com/ClutchPoints/status/1782127516443930847
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,504
The reason they have that rep is that they do a lot of dirty things, of course.

Why does Martin duck, in your interpretation? That is the dirty part and it clearly has nothing to do with the push (which is directional, not down). That's what you cannot do on any playground in America, go low on a jumping player.

What you guys are saying fits for Martin running into Tatum high. But the evidence actually shows him ducking. That just isn't about Jrue.
Have none of you guys ever trying to regain your balance when stumbling forward? The only direction you can go is low.
 

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,551
So, the "it was clean" argument requires him BOTH to be 'not low' and 'low because he was stumbling' Got it!!!!

I do not see him stumbling at all, fwiw.

The most sympathetic realistic explanation is that he was charging hard for a rebound, got brushed off by Jrue and 'accidentally' undercut Tatum. Anything that denies he undercut Tatum is just not credible from the replay.

So we're left with the question: did a guy who wasn't stumbling, and purposefully turned his back so it would be under Tatum rather than his face (confirming he was not out of control or stumbling) know he was undercutting a guy in the air he was looking directly at or not? I think it's pretty clear he knew where he was and where Tatum was and that's why he turned his body. And that to me is the clear tell
 

the moops

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 19, 2016
4,784
Saint Paul, MN
I don't hate Bam, but definitely don't think he is a TOP20-30 NBA player.
IMO defense-first Centers, that run around screening on offense are a great place to find value in the NBA

Question, would you swap KP for Bam for these playoffs?
I would swap KP for Bam. It’s close and it would completely change how the team plays but I think Bam with the other 4 starters would be the best defense in the league. Bam is clearly a top 25’ish player in this league. There is a reason Miami has performed so well these past few years. Yes Spo, and yes Butler, but Bam is who allows them to play all their different defense and is deservedly in the defensive player of the year convo every year.

The “we will just have Tillman provide 90% of what Bam gave us”
seems ludicrous to me and completely discounts how good of a basketball player Bam is.
 

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,448
The reason they have that rep is that they do a lot of dirty things, of course.

Why does Martin duck, in your interpretation? That is the dirty part and it clearly has nothing to do with the push (which is directional, not down). That's what you cannot do on any playground in America, go low on a jumping player.

What you guys are saying fits for Martin running into Tatum high. But the evidence actually shows him ducking. That just isn't about Jrue.
We've played two intense 7-game series against them the past two seasons, and, when asked for examples of their "lot of dirty things", people are like "Bam sets illegal screens" and "they grab us a lot."

I have no idea why Martin ducks. I haven't been pushed while running full speed for a loose ball in an NBA game, so it's hard to say.

It feels like people are desperately hoping Martin did something dirty so they'd finally have the evidence of Dirty Heat Play they've been looking for.
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,504
So, the "it was clean" argument requires him BOTH to be 'not low' and 'low because he was stumbling' Got it!!!!

I do not see him stumbling at all, fwiw.

The most sympathetic realistic explanation is that he was charging hard for a rebound, got brushed off by Jrue and 'accidentally' undercut Tatum. Anything that denies he undercut Tatum is just not credible from the replay.

So we're left with the question: did a guy who wasn't stumbling, and purposefully turned his back so it would be under Tatum rather than his face (confirming he was not out of control or stumbling) know he was undercutting a guy in the air he was looking directly at or not? I think it's pretty clear he knew where he was and where Tatum was and that's why he turned his body. And that to me is the clear tell
You didn’t see him pushed off balance into Tatum? I mean if you don’t see that I suppose no sense discussing further. Martin’s instinctual reaction was to help Tatum up as well.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,051
So, the "it was clean" argument requires him BOTH to be 'not low' and 'low because he was stumbling' Got it!!!!

I do not see him stumbling at all, fwiw.

The most sympathetic realistic explanation is that he was charging hard for a rebound, got brushed off by Jrue and 'accidentally' undercut Tatum. Anything that denies he undercut Tatum is just not credible from the replay.

So we're left with the question: did a guy who wasn't stumbling, and purposefully turned his back so it would be under Tatum rather than his face (confirming he was not out of control or stumbling) know he was undercutting a guy in the air he was looking directly at or not? I think it's pretty clear he knew where he was and where Tatum was and that's why he turned his body. And that to me is the clear tell
I say this in the nicest way..... you are delusional. We have tape... he runs in exactly the way you run in if you are going to jump to contest a rebound... he is then pushed in the back by a large strong man, he then doesn't jump in time and crashes into the player before he can leave his feet. he hits side to side with Tatum, but Tatum got to jump.

Nobody but the most insanely delusional people are arguing it's anything but missed timing, hell even Bill Simmons brushed it off as nothing and he LOVES a conspiracy.
 

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,551
HRB, I do not see him off balance. He turns his body a couple steps after the Jrue contact---that's just a really odd motion.

Cellar Door, lose the attitude, this forum is a lot better than that post.
 

bigq

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
11,279
I would swap KP for Bam. It’s close and it would completely change how the team plays but I think Bam with the other 4 starters would be the best defense in the league. Bam is clearly a top 25’ish player in this league. There is a reason Miami has performed so well these past few years. Yes Spo, and yes Butler, but Bam is who allows them to play all their different defense and is deservedly in the defensive player of the year convo every year.

The “we will just have Tillman provide 90% of what Bam gave us”
seems ludicrous to me and completely discounts how good of a basketball player Bam is.
Hmmm. I don't think I would right now but maybe in 2-3 years. I like the way KP spaces the floor and gets mismatches on pick and roll on offense and I think his defense is pretty good - he alters a ton of shots in a way that Bam does not. Bam is two years younger and may age better but KP is the better all around player right now.
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,504
HRB, I do not see him off balance. He turns his body a couple steps after the Jrue contact---that's just a really odd motion.

Cellar Door, lose the attitude, this forum is a lot better than that post.
I think you are misinterpreting him turning his body a couple steps after being pushed with him losing body control after moving forward then being pushed in the back.
 

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,551
I think you are misinterpreting him turning his body a couple steps after being pushed with him losing body control after moving forward then being pushed in the back.
I don't see any evidence of him losing body control before the turn...to me his gait and step don't change until he decides to turn (though he was knocled a bit off his original line by the contact). I guess you could argue he saw his choice as "go lower and hope you don't foul him" or "grab Tatum" because he was going to collide with him either way. But how he collides---that to me is the issue, looks to me like he turns to get under Tatum and almost surely knew what he was doing there.

As with many things like this, trying to interpret intent (or lack of it) is challenging.
 

Auger34

used to be tbb
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
9,726
I am not sure if the play was dirty..but Martin clearly jumps. I mean both feet are off the ground when he hits Tatum.

hes definitely shoved and it kind of looks like he doesn’t even realize Tatum is there?

I don’t know if this play is dirty but the Heat have absolutely earned their reps for being dirty.
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,329
I searched pretty hard to find intent because I hate this team with a passion but think it was just incidental. I would question why the dude was crashing the boards like prime Russell Westbrook down 16 with a minute to go but whatever.

My biggest takeaway is that I’m just incredibly glad that we avoided disaster with that play. Tatum’s head was very close to slamming into the ground and you easily could have had a knee/ankle sprain with slightly different timing.

With all that said, if Jaylen wants to use this as motivation to drop 35 on these guys in Game 2, I’m all for it.
 

InstaFace

The Ultimate One
SoSH Member
Sep 27, 2016
22,360
Pittsburgh, PA
I hope everyone got to see the other angle of the Tatum/Martin play that showed Jrue shoving Martin into Tatum. Zero percent chance there was anything intentional or dirty about the play. Not sure what Jrue was doing/thinking though.
81390

edit: ok jokes aside, after Zaprudering that thing a bit, my read is: Martin was taking steps in order to set himself to jump high and contest the rebound with Tatum. But Jrue's shove meant his "gather step" to prep the jump happened like a foot closer to Tatum that he intended, and by the time he could get his feet under him, he was under Tatum.

He might've been thinking he'd bump Tatum in the air a bit, but I do think the push took him out of his intended positioning enough that it probably wasn't a dirty play. And I'm nobody's idea of a Heat fan.
 
Last edited:

Jimbodandy

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 31, 2006
11,627
around the way
I would swap KP for Bam. It’s close and it would completely change how the team plays but I think Bam with the other 4 starters would be the best defense in the league. Bam is clearly a top 25’ish player in this league. There is a reason Miami has performed so well these past few years. Yes Spo, and yes Butler, but Bam is who allows them to play all their different defense and is deservedly in the defensive player of the year convo every year.

The “we will just have Tillman provide 90% of what Bam gave us”
seems ludicrous to me and completely discounts how good of a basketball player Bam is.
I agree with most of this post. Bam is a very good defender. But you have to stop calling him a top 20/25 player. No team built around Bam Adebayo is frightening anyone in the playoffs ever. He's a #2 guy, really a #3 guy on a very good team.

Darko has him at 45 in the Brandon Ingram, Lauri Markkaren range. Lebron has him at 39 this year between fellow big men Myles Turner and Chet Holmgren. Seems about right.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
35,051
I agree with most of this post. Bam is a very good defender. But you have to stop calling him a top 20/25 player. No team built around Bam Adebayo is frightening anyone in the playoffs ever. He's a #2 guy, really a #3 guy on a very good team.

Darko has him at 45 in the Brandon Ingram, Lauri Markkaren range. Lebron has him at 39 this year between fellow big men Myles Turner and Chet Holmgren. Seems about right.
To me Bam is basically Draymond with some extra post offense. His value is he's an incredibly versatile big defender who should be in the DPOY conversation most years... but he's not going to be your offensive #1, and he's probably best served as the #3.