Bill Duffy wouldn't be the first agent to bend the truth to benefit his client
I don't really want to go down the
JC vs Ayton rabbit hole since they play different positions/styles. They've been pretty similar with PPG, Steals, Blocks, Asst/TO, VORP, BPM etc...IMO they are very high-end complementary players. Personally, I'd rather have JC, but a lot of that has to do with the style of Ayton's play and the ability to get that style at a cheaper price.
The Suns probably noticed that the team was better on D (and net efficient) when JaVale McGee (12-5 when he started) played Center with the 4 other starters. Clearly, Ayton is > McGee BUT they probably asked themselves is it really worth MAXing Ayton when they can get McGee on the cheap? Warriors model, shooting + experienced BIG. I'm sure the SUNS have their regrets from drafting him #1 and don't want to double down on that mistake with a MAX deal (+ Sarver is cheap)
Also, the lack of 3pt FGA is a red flag. Maybe that's a
Ben Simmons reflex reaction?
DA has been a consistent 75% FT shooter since his rookie year, how does he start/play big minutes for 4 seasons and only have 19 3PA this season? It's something every NBA team has been encouraging players to do for years. The SUNS would be privy to his work ethic on that front. If they saw that coming around I imagine they would have had a different stance this season.
If a team wants to spend $100M over 4yrs with the hopes of more development, I guess. There is more cap space available this summer which should help his cause.