Celtics vs. Heat, Round 3 Discussion

Who you got?


  • Total voters
    333
  • Poll closed .

Salem's Lot

Andy Moog! Andy God Damn Moog!
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
14,630
Gallows Hill
Whoever took those pictures of White on a plane is a creep. And Bertrand is even worse for tweeting them.

Is that the same caller that’s always following the players wives around? They really shouldn’t encourage that guy.
 

Mugsy's Jock

Eli apologist
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 28, 2000
15,115
UWS, NYC
Wait, what?

Are you speculating, or is that actually reported anywhere? Didn't find anything just now, after unclutching my heart.
Okay, now it's widely reported.

So... I guess I'm a terrible cranky old man, but assuming there's no health challenges associated with the impending blessing I'd sure have hoped DW would've been okay waiting a day.

And now I'll book passage to hell.
 

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,240
Khris Middleton, an All-Star who's regularly torched the Celtics, missed the entire second-round series.
Yes, other teams get injuries, and they helped the Celtics in this case. But the Bucks got to make multiple playoff runs with all their guys healthy in the last 5 years (interestingly, not when they won the title).

I don't know that another team has had worse injury luck with core players:
2018: Hayward, Kyrie
2019: Hayward still not back, Smart hurt initially against Mil
2020: Hayward again, Kemba's knee disintegrates
2021: no Jaylen, no Kemba, no TL
2022: no TL, now no Smart and Horford and White (for 1 game)

It's like if Milwaukee had the Middleton thing happen every single year.
 

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,464
Hingham, MA
Yes, other teams get injuries, and they helped the Celtics in this case. But the Bucks got to make multiple playoff runs with all their guys healthy in the last 5 years (interestingly, not when they won the title).

I don't know that another team has had worse injury luck with core players:
2018: Hayward, Kyrie
2019: Hayward still not back, Smart hurt initially against Mil
2020: Hayward again, Kemba's knee disintegrates
2021: no Jaylen, no Kemba, no TL
2022: no TL, now no Smart and Horford and White (for 1 game)

It's like if Milwaukee had the Middleton thing happen every single year.
Plus injuries happen. Smart and TL, that’s normal.

The Horford and White situations are just horrible luck.
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,257
Plus injuries happen. Smart and TL, that’s normal.

The Horford and White situations are just horrible luck.
It’s ridiculous. All this hard work and resilience to get here and then this happens. Over and over again. Oh well, need to win tonight regardless so hope the team rises to the challenge.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
11,874
Yes, other teams get injuries, and they helped the Celtics in this case. But the Bucks got to make multiple playoff runs with all their guys healthy in the last 5 years (interestingly, not when they won the title).

I don't know that another team has had worse injury luck with core players:
2018: Hayward, Kyrie
2019: Hayward still not back, Smart hurt initially against Mil
2020: Hayward again, Kemba's knee disintegrates
2021: no Jaylen, no Kemba, no TL
2022: no TL, now no Smart and Horford and White (for 1 game)

It's like if Milwaukee had the Middleton thing happen every single year.
Go back further and you have Perkins getting hurt.. Garnett.. Rondo getting intentionally hurt by Wade etc

edit: if there’s one team that has had incredible injury luck with opponents getting hurt throughout history.. it’s the Heat. Someone from every contender has been hurt against them in pretty much all of their runs through the playoffs.. including during the LeBron era. LeBron has had incredible luck until recently with other teams injuries in the playoffs
 
Last edited:

Tudor Fever

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 16, 2004
3,682
Maine
You know what? This is all a set-up for the Cs becoming the first NBA team ever to go down 3 games to 0 and then come back to win the series.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
11,874
It’s ridiculous. All this hard work and resilience to get here and then this happens. Over and over again. Oh well, need to win tonight regardless so hope the team rises to the challenge.
Just need to win one of four away.. and hold serve at home. Hopefully all are ready to go on Saturday
 

NavaHo

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 29, 2010
323
More big minutes for PP tonight. Hopefully they have an adjustment ready after Miami ruthlessly hunted him on defense in the 2nd half of game 1. I think we need to pray for a hot shooting night.
 

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,240
You know what? This is all a set-up for the Cs becoming the first NBA team ever to go down 3 games to 0 and then come back to win the series.
I do have more confidence in this team to come back from 2-0 than nearly any Celtics team I've rooted for, just in terms of mental toughness. Bring it on.

But yeah, as noted by others, the post-2008 era has been filled with nutpunches, at an abnormally high level.
 

BrotherMouzone

New Member
Aug 2, 2010
142
Okay, now it's widely reported.

So... I guess I'm a terrible cranky old man, but assuming there's no health challenges associated with the impending blessing I'd sure have hoped DW would've been okay waiting a day.

And now I'll book passage to hell.
Yeah, this is a trash take. We're talking about a basketball game. Have some perspective.
 

jablo1312

New Member
Sep 20, 2005
985
The 3s are great but they need to start getting into the paint and get some easier baskets.
Go back further and you have Perkins getting hurt.. Garnett.. Rondo getting intentionally hurt by Wade etc

edit: if there’s one team that has had incredible injury luck with opponents getting hurt throughout history.. it’s the Heat. Someone from every contender has been hurt against them in pretty much all of their runs through the playoffs.. including during the LeBron era. LeBron has had incredible luck until recently with other teams injuries in the playoffs
Chris Bosh missed all most of the conference semi's and finals in 2012 (his absence played a role in the Celts going up 3-2 in that series). Kevin Love missed all of the 2015 playoffs, and the Cavs very well might have won the title if him and Kyrie (out for the Finals) both play vs GSW that year.

Didn't the 2020 heat lose Dragic to foot injury for most of the Finals? They're missing their 30M a year point guard right now. Even going back a bit, Wade got hurt in 2005 otherwise they probably beat the Pistons and make the Finals that year.
 

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,464
Hingham, MA
You know what? This is all a set-up for the Cs becoming the first NBA team ever to go down 3 games to 0 and then come back to win the series.
They're not going to fall behind 3-0.

I have full confidence that even if they lose tonight, they take this to 6 or 7 games.

And if they win tonight, they're winning this in six or fewer.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
11,874
Chris Bosh missed all most of the conference semi's and finals in 2012 (his absence played a role in the Celts going up 3-2 in that series). Kevin Love missed all of the 2015 playoffs, and the Cavs very well might have won the title if him and Kyrie (out for the Finals) both play vs GSW that year.

Didn't the 2020 heat lose Dragic to foot injury for most of the Finals? They're missing their 30M a year point guard right now. Even going back a bit, Wade got hurt in 2005 otherwise they probably beat the Pistons and make the Finals that year.
I once went through all of LeBrons early playoff runs.. each time he won there seemed to be injuries to major players of every major contender that year.. but you raise some good points.
Lowry has only been out two games though? Or was he out against Philly? Hard to argue they’ve had bad luck this year given their run so far and these first two Boston games..
 

Coachster

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 3, 2009
8,987
New Hampshire
More big minutes for PP tonight. Hopefully they have an adjustment ready after Miami ruthlessly hunted him on defense in the 2nd half of game 1. I think we need to pray for a hot shooting night.
I wonder if Ime will use Nesmith instead of PP for White's minutes. Better defense, and there isn't much difference in their shooting. (Of course, this is assuming Smart can play 35-40 minutes....)
 

NomarsFool

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2001
8,258
Ugh. My day is ruined :)

If for some reason Smart can't go or is limited, who the heck is the next man up at guard? Do we just go with no real ballhandler and let Tatum bring the ball up the floor?
 

Pablo's TB Lover

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 10, 2017
6,010
Chris Bosh missed all most of the conference semi's and finals in 2012 (his absence played a role in the Celts going up 3-2 in that series). Kevin Love missed all of the 2015 playoffs, and the Cavs very well might have won the title if him and Kyrie (out for the Finals) both play vs GSW that year.

Didn't the 2020 heat lose Dragic to foot injury for most of the Finals? They're missing their 30M a year point guard right now. Even going back a bit, Wade got hurt in 2005 otherwise they probably beat the Pistons and make the Finals that year.
Stop bringing your facts, we're trying to have a pity party over here! ;)
 

NomarsFool

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2001
8,258
I wonder if Ime will use Nesmith instead of PP for White's minutes. Better defense, and there isn't much difference in their shooting. (Of course, this is assuming Smart can play 35-40 minutes....)
I think Nesmith is actually a worse shooter than White, somehow. He had one shot the other night that I don't think even hit the rim.
 

nighthob

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
12,712
More big minutes for PP tonight. Hopefully they have an adjustment ready after Miami ruthlessly hunted him on defense in the 2nd half of game 1. I think we need to pray for a hot shooting night.
The big minutes for Pritchard aren’t the problem, per se. With Smart hobbled it means Pritchard and Nesmith. If only Boston could combine them into a single player they’d have something.
 

Euclis20

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 3, 2004
8,227
Imaginationland
Didn't the 2020 heat lose Dragic to foot injury for most of the Finals? They're missing their 30M a year point guard right now. Even going back a bit, Wade got hurt in 2005 otherwise they probably beat the Pistons and make the Finals that year.
Lowry isn't as important to the Heat as Horford or Smart are to the Celtics, but to your point, the 2020 Heat lost both Dragic AND Bam from a couple of finals games.

Yes, other teams get injuries, and they helped the Celtics in this case. But the Bucks got to make multiple playoff runs with all their guys healthy in the last 5 years (interestingly, not when they won the title).

I don't know that another team has had worse injury luck with core players:
2018: Hayward, Kyrie
2019: Hayward still not back, Smart hurt initially against Mil
2020: Hayward again, Kemba's knee disintegrates
2021: no Jaylen, no Kemba, no TL
2022: no TL, now no Smart and Horford and White (for 1 game)

It's like if Milwaukee had the Middleton thing happen every single year.
Go back just one more year to 2017: Isaiah Thomas missed the last 3 games of the conference finals against Cleveland (and scored just 2 points in game 2). Both the Cavs and Warriors were healthy and at the height of their powers that year so it probably wouldn't have mattered, but IT finished 5th in MVP voting and was 2nd team all-NBA, and the Celtics had home-court against the Cavs and had always played the Warriors tough. We had a punchers chance, and the IT injury ended that. Just a brutal stretch of injuries.
 

Auger34

used to be tbb
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
9,616
Chris Bosh missed all most of the conference semi's and finals in 2012 (his absence played a role in the Celts going up 3-2 in that series). Kevin Love missed all of the 2015 playoffs, and the Cavs very well might have won the title if him and Kyrie (out for the Finals) both play vs GSW that year.

Didn't the 2020 heat lose Dragic to foot injury for most of the Finals? They're missing their 30M a year point guard right now. Even going back a bit, Wade got hurt in 2005 otherwise they probably beat the Pistons and make the Finals that year.
Kyle Lowry has been on and off the court all year, and when he’s actually played he’s looked a lot older. The Heat have had a chance to play without him and adjust.

Think it’s a bit different with something like that then with something like Horford/Smart/White (the other examples you listed definitely fit)
 

Auger34

used to be tbb
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
9,616
I think Nesmith is actually a worse shooter than White, somehow. He had one shot the other night that I don't think even hit the rim.
It was his first shot and it wasn’t even close. From the moment it left his hand it looked way too long and flat
 

nighthob

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
12,712
Didn't the 2020 heat lose Dragic to foot injury for most of the Finals? They're missing their 30M a year point guard right now. Even going back a bit, Wade got hurt in 2005 otherwise they probably beat the Pistons and make the Finals that year.
Complaining that the 2020 Heat lost Goran Dragic is the equivalent to an otherwise completely healthy ‘22 Celtics complaining about the loss of Pritchard. The 34 year old Dragic had already reached the couldn’t defend Kobe to a roomful of Laker fans stage of his career. A defensive team losing its two best defenders and two most reliable ball handlers is just a liiiiiitle difference. (Also, while Lowry is going to make an average $28 million per for his ages 35-37 seasons, it was a bad deal when the Heat offered it.)
 

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,240
Chris Bosh missed all most of the conference semi's and finals in 2012 (his absence played a role in the Celts going up 3-2 in that series). Kevin Love missed all of the 2015 playoffs, and the Cavs very well might have won the title if him and Kyrie (out for the Finals) both play vs GSW that year.

Didn't the 2020 heat lose Dragic to foot injury for most of the Finals? They're missing their 30M a year point guard right now. Even going back a bit, Wade got hurt in 2005 otherwise they probably beat the Pistons and make the Finals that year.
The notable thing about the Celtics past 5 years isn't that they've had injuries to top-3 players on the team--that happens to every team at times. it's that they've had those injuries basically every year while going on deep playoff runs in that time.
 

Jimbodandy

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 31, 2006
11,528
around the way
I do have more confidence in this team to come back from 2-0 than nearly any Celtics team I've rooted for, just in terms of mental toughness. Bring it on.

But yeah, as noted by others, the post-2008 era has been filled with nutpunches, at an abnormally high level.
Yeah Red's unicorn blood ran out long before 2008. Len Bias dropping dead killed the last dynasty. If you're 35 or younger, you've been alive for as many Bruins championships as Celtics ones. And the Bruins owner measures success in empty beer cups.
 

wilked

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 17, 2005
4,066
First, if his wife is on labor of course he will want to be there. To think otherwise is ridiculous

secondly, if like me you were confused that the person in the picture is clearly not 9 months pregnant, that is not his wife.

 

cshea

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 15, 2006
36,245
306, row 14
It seems strange to go from doubtful to questionable forwhen in a the protocol. Like did he pass 1 test and he needs to pass 2 to clear? Like what would change to make him go from doubtful to questionable? I feel like if he cleared some testing/protocol hurdle, it would be doubtful to probable?
 

A Bad Man

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2016
1,050
It seems strange to go from doubtful to questionable forwhen in a the protocol. Like did he pass 1 test and he needs to pass 2 to clear? Like what would change to make him go from doubtful to questionable? I feel like if he cleared some testing/protocol hurdle, it would be doubtful to probable?
 

DGreenwood

Member
SoSH Member
Feb 2, 2003
2,468
Seattle
It seems strange to go from doubtful to questionable forwhen in a the protocol. Like did he pass 1 test and he needs to pass 2 to clear? Like what would change to make him go from doubtful to questionable? I feel like if he cleared some testing/protocol hurdle, it would be doubtful to probable?
One negative test, but still needing a second, was the exact scenario I thought of that could lead to a change from doubtful to questionable.
 

Red Averages

owes you $50
SoSH Member
Apr 20, 2003
9,176
I’m guessing the NBA is scrambling and letting him play. Likely under the “reduced viral load” vagueness.
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,360
It was his first shot and it wasn’t even close. From the moment it left his hand it looked way too long and flat
Nesmith’s second shot was even worse and he can’t stay in front of his man on the other end. His greatest strength is weak side shot blocking. Such a bizarre skillset he’s developed.
 

nighthob

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
12,712
I think Nesmith is actually a worse shooter than White, somehow. He had one shot the other night that I don't think even hit the rim.
Nesmith doesn’t believe that his shot’s going in at all and you can see it when he shoots. If there’s a defender within closing distance he’s rushing his shot and screwing up his mechanics. When he’s wide open there’s always that hesitation to pull the trigger. He’s regressed badly on offense this year.

The infuriating part is that he’s turned into a much better defender than I expected. If he could get out of his head he could be a decent 3&D guy.
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,379
Santa Monica
Nesmith’s second shot was even worse and he can’t stay in front of his man on the other end. His greatest strength is weak side shot blocking. Such a bizarre skillset he’s developed.
nothing makes sense with the guy

he came with the reputation of a knockdown 3pt shooter with limited athleticism

he bricks it from deep and runs around the floor like he's Carl Lewis

you can live with him as your 10th player in the playoffs, as long as he doesn't shoot and focuses on making energy plays (weak side help and offensive boards)
 

ilol@u

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 2, 2009
4,246
Foxboro
If the NBA is actually rigged, they would want Al to play. This team without Horford, White and a gimpy Smart will not win game 2.
 

wade boggs chicken dinner

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 26, 2005
30,811
Nesmith doesn’t believe that his shot’s going in at all and you can see it when he shoots. If there’s a defender within closing distance he’s rushing his shot and screwing up his mechanics. When he’s wide open there’s always that hesitation to pull the trigger. He’s regressed badly on offense this year.

The infuriating part is that he’s turned into a much better defender than I expected. If he could get out of his head he could be a decent 3&D guy.
It's not that he doesn't believe, he's just over-excited. He's not relaxed. He's basically trying too hard as he's bound and determined not to screw up, which is a horrible place for any athlete to be.
 

Strike4

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
3,910
Portland, Maine
Since it advances the thread, here's Chris Bosh at the Lincoln Memorial on Easter Sunday doing a photo shoot with his family. There were like hundreds of people there and only me and one other guy seemed to recognize him. Which is actually great for him.

Edit: @HomeRunBaker


51736
 

Euclis20

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 3, 2004
8,227
Imaginationland
Nesmith’s second shot was even worse and he can’t stay in front of his man on the other end. His greatest strength is weak side shot blocking. Such a bizarre skillset he’s developed.
He's got 14 blocks in 98 career games (regular season), and has a career average of .4 blocks per 36 minutes. Before game 1, he had 1 block in about 83 playoff minutes. That's not terrible for a 6'5 shooting guard, but if it's his greatest strength he'll never play another meaningful minute again on a healthy team, and he won't get a second NBA contract.

He plays like he's forever filled with the energy and IQ of a guy who just got drafted last week. He overplays everything on defense (which can lead to some blocks if the other team is unprepared, tons of dumb fouls and a total inability to consistently stay in front of his man) and despite good form, never finds the range on offense. Tremendously disappointing that this is where he is at the end of year 2.
 

dhellers

Member
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2005
4,267
Silver Spring, Maryland
I observe it being both---he is great at creating angles and contact...and he gets calls that are not merited in part because of his rep and in part because he creates contact.
I mostly-ignore the "Tatum doesn't get superstar calls" complaints around here. That's the NBA.

BUT GDIT if Butler is going to get calls on anything that might look like a foul, then Tatum etc SHOULD GET similar consideration.
I don't expect a miracle of Tatum getting the superstar calls, but at least give him the benefit of the doubt.

SO yeah, it pisses me off. At least Giannis was making moves, rather than Hardenizing most of the time.

BTW: One of Butler's greatest abilities is how he can allocate his physical/mental resources to when they are needed. His ability to coast for a while, and then turn it on.
IOW: he can't go all out all game.

Why let that arrogant sob get away with it? When he is coasting mode, ATTACK HIM. Either he is ineffective, or he has to pay attention earlier than he plans.
Either outcome is a good thing.
 

Auger34

used to be tbb
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
9,616
Two of his 3 blocks in this game came as the lone guy back on a Miami fast break.
Yeah..those 2 blocks were incredible. His shot was absolute shit but no need to discredit some phenomenal individual effort and defense
 

NomarsFool

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2001
8,258
One negative test, but still needing a second, was the exact scenario I thought of that could lead to a change from doubtful to questionable.
It would seem a bit odd to have a positive test, followed by a negative test, followed by a positive test again - assuming the negative test was administered correctly.

To put it another way, if he had a negative test, it certainly would seem more likely than not his next test is also negative.