College Football - General Discussion

canderson

Mr. Brightside
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
39,558
Harrisburg, Pa.

OCST

Sunny von Bulow
SoSH Member
Jan 10, 2004
24,539
The 718
I used to respect Tim Tebow. I thought his ostentatious religiosity was off-putting, but he seemed like a good competitor and a decent guy.

But this?:

Tim Tebow harshly criticized Maryland's administration behind DJ Durkin's flip-flop firing earlier this week, arguing that the university showed low character for not sticking to its word and what he perceived as ultimately caving in response to negative publicity.

"You need to make a decision and you need to stand with it," Tebow said in an appearance on ESPN's First Take on Friday. "Because right now (the decision to fire Durkin) shows people are so afraid to have conviction to believe in something when they make a decision that they're like, 'oh my goodness social media's against us. Well we're gonna fire him now.' You just made a decision to keep him. If that's your decision, if you believe that's what's right for the program, then it shouldn't matter what I say, what social media says.

"So many people want to be liked instead of being respected. And I think more universities need to stand by what they believe is right."
https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/ncaaf/2018/11/02/tim-tebow-rips-maryland-firing-dj-durking-after-retaining-coach/1859600002/

That's just vile. Stomach-turning really.
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
73,070
He's right in the sense that they should have fired him the second after the manslaughter, not hold him and then fire him after the media pressure.
 

canderson

Mr. Brightside
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
39,558
Harrisburg, Pa.
Purple Wizard might announce his retirement this week, perhaps as early as Tuesday. No link but Buddy is a journalist and has heard some rumblings.
 

SoxJox

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2003
7,133
Rock > SoxJox < Hard Place
Stories / rumors starting to ripple out that James Franklin could be considered / headed for USC. This story offers 10 reasons why that could happen. [My Take]

1. USC is a better job than Penn State [Arguable, but not an outlandish position to take]
2. The thrill is gone [Perhaps, but he still seems pretty excited to me. I think he sincerely believes he can...and wants to...bring a NC to Happy Valley. That is not an impossible dream.]
3. Weather and lifestyle. [No argument]
4. Franklin's personality is a perfect LA fit. [No argument]
5. Franklin's recruiting background almost entirely east of the Mississippi does not matter. [Not so sure about this. While Franklin has left a great deal of the heavy lifting in recruiting to his staff, his own energy, personal knowledge of and involvement in recruiting has played an important part in PSU's recent resurgence. He has more recently dipped into FL, TX, and has placed feet in CA, but he'll still be at somewhat of a disadvantage early on in the west. However, in some ways, his reputation as a recruiter may precede him]
6. Sandy Barbour's future as AD is unknown [Sandy Barbour ain't nowhere anytime soon...although she could give him tips about the PAC-12, given her Cal roots]
7. Being an African-American coach might be easier in a large, diverse city. [There is no evidence anywhere that race has played any part, one way or the other, in Franklin and his family's integration into the State College community. It would not appear - at least on the surface - that it could be described as "difficult", which the relative characterization of "easier" implies.].
8. Lynn Swann could hire USC's first black head football coach. [An attractive piece of potential history and personal legacy to dangle. He's already claimed "first black" head coach at Vandy and PSU. Perhaps the added benny of a fellow black naming him is a tempting one-two punch.]
9. The Pac-12 South is so much easier than the Big Ten East [Given the historical and collective histories, no contest. True.]
10. James Franklin has never gathered moss. [What coach in the modern era has? The list of top-20 longest tenured coaches is below]

Coach, school, year hired
1. Kirk Ferentz, Iowa, 1999
2. Gary Patterson, TCU, 2000
T3. Mike Gundy, Oklahoma State, 2005
T3. Frank Solich, Ohio, 2005
T3. Kyle Whittingham, Utah, 2005
T6. Pat Fitzgerald, Northwestern, 2006
T6. Rick Stockstill, Mid. Tennessee St., 2006
T8. Ken Niumatalolo, Navy, 2007
T8. Mark Dantonio, Michigan State, 2007
T8. David Bailiff, Rice, 2007
T8. Troy Calhoun, Air Force, 2007
T8. Nick Saban, Alabama, 2007
T13. Dabo Swinney, Clemson, 2008
T13. David Cutcliffe, Duke, 2008
T13. Paul Johnson, Georgia Tech, 2008
T13. Bobby Wilder, Old Dominion, 2008
T17. Dan Mullen, Mississippi State, 2009
T17. Bill Snyder, Kansas State, 2009
T17. Joey Jones, South Alabama, 2009
T20. Doc Holliday, Marshall, 2010
T20. Jimbo Fisher, Florida State, 2010
T20. Brian Kelly, Notre Dame, 2010




 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
73,070
I disagree with the LA personality. He doesn't have the laid-back, Pete Carroll, aw shucks, personality. JF almost always looks too angry.

Also, Jimbo Fisher is no longer at FSU. And Dan Mullen is no longer at Miss St.
 

SoxJox

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2003
7,133
Rock > SoxJox < Hard Place
Yeah, the list is a bit dated.

And, on cue, Franklin dismisses the speculation.

In an attempt yesterday — a failed attempt — to try to keep the focus on Maryland, I got asked a question yesterday about another school and tried to keep the focus on Maryland like I always do and the next opponent, and that didn’t go over very well. I didn’t feel like it was appropriate to talk about another school or another person’s job status, so that’s why I addressed it the way I did. But, obviously, I have all the plans in the world to be here and to be here for a long time, so I just wanted to address that because it became something that I did not want it to be or intend. So I wanted to put that statement out there and then obviously would love to talk about Maryland and our practice today.
 

soxhop411

news aggravator
SoSH Member
Dec 4, 2009
46,417
I think Clay Helton is gone by Tuesday if USC doesn’t win today.

Though USC will fuck it up again and hire an alumni
 

garlan5

Member
SoSH Member
May 13, 2009
2,684
Virginia
Turner Gill steps down as Liberty Flames head coach due to wife's heart condition. Rumor is Hugh Freeze as possible replacement..
 

PaulinMyrBch

Don't touch his dog food
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 10, 2003
8,316
MYRTLE BEACH!!!!
Kelly Bryant picked Missouri. Made some sense, they have no QB in the wings after Lock and they have a good amount of returning offensive players at skill positions. He should have a good chance to showcase what he can do at that school.
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
24,616
I'm back thinking about UCF. No power 5 conference wants them. So they're stuck in a crappy conference. Not really their fault. And they can't really schedule power 5 schools in their non-conference games, because most of those power 5 schools won't touch UCF as a non-conference opponent, because their conference schedules are already hard enough and they want a few cupcakes in there. Plus...money.

http://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/25479055/florida-gators-ad-scott-stricklin-welcome-2-1-series-vs-ucf-knights

Florida will schedule UCF, but only in a scheduling scenario that is advantage Florida.

So what is UCF supposed to do? They try to make a difficult schedule. They managed to schedule UNC (not good, but a power 5 school...cancelled due to hurricane) and Pitt (who was pretty decent). But they'll never get a big big time program on their schedule without putting themselves at a major disadvantage.

But maybe that's what they'll have to do. Maybe they simply say, look, we'll play you guys on the road, sure. And see how that goes. I dunno.
 

EvilEmpire

paying for his sins
Moderator
SoSH Member
Apr 9, 2007
17,259
Washington
I think UCF should take the 2 for 1s when they can get them. Win enough of those games and the whining about how unfair the rankings are will have more merit.
 

The Needler

New Member
Dec 7, 2016
1,803
I'm back thinking about UCF. No power 5 conference wants them. So they're stuck in a crappy conference. Not really their fault. And they can't really schedule power 5 schools in their non-conference games, because most of those power 5 schools won't touch UCF as a non-conference opponent, because their conference schedules are already hard enough and they want a few cupcakes in there. Plus...money.

http://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/25479055/florida-gators-ad-scott-stricklin-welcome-2-1-series-vs-ucf-knights

Florida will schedule UCF, but only in a scheduling scenario that is advantage Florida.

So what is UCF supposed to do? They try to make a difficult schedule. They managed to schedule UNC (not good, but a power 5 school...cancelled due to hurricane) and Pitt (who was pretty decent). But they'll never get a big big time program on their schedule without putting themselves at a major disadvantage.

But maybe that's what they'll have to do. Maybe they simply say, look, we'll play you guys on the road, sure. And see how that goes. I dunno.
Boo hoo. They were 6-7 two years ago, and 0-12 the year before that. These games are scheduled years in advance, and nobody is going to risk millions of dollars to schedule a home and home against a nobody team that could be back to FCS level three years from now. Put up sustained excellence, and they will come. Otherwise, take your 2-for-1 and one offs against traditional powers, or just keep hanging your moral victory banners.

EDIT: And don’t give me the “not really their fault,” and “managed to schedule UNC” BS. As I said, these games are scheduled years in advance. The UCF series was agreed to in the summer of 2016, with UCF coming off an 0-12 season. If you think Alabama, LSU, OSU, Michigan type schools wouldn’t have happily thrown them on the home schedule this year or next, and thrown in a million bucks for good measure, you’re fooling yourself. UCF wanted a home and home, and in no way were they deserving of one with an elite school as a bottom-feeding program in a mid major conference. But if they wanted a game, they could’ve had one.
 
Last edited:

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,322
Hingham, MA
Boo hoo. They were 6-7 two years ago, and 0-12 the year before that. These games are scheduled years in advance, and nobody is going to risk millions of dollars to schedule a home and home against a nobody team that could be back to FCS level three years from now. Put up sustained excellence, and they will come. Otherwise, take your 2-for-1 and one offs against traditional powers, or just keep hanging your moral victory banners.
I lean toward your take. They aren't in position to be stubborn and wait for a home-and-home series. They won't schedule a top program that way. Take your 2 for 1, win the games when they matter, and that will accomplish what they need to do. Go to the Swamp and win, and everyone will take them (more) seriously.
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,027
Not sure if any of you follow FCS football, but perennial powerhouse, and #1 seed in the playoffs, North Dakota State, is playing #8 Colgate right now on ESPN. It's pretty good stuff. Colgate comes in after beating another perennial power, James Madison. NDSU has won like 4 of the last 5 national championships.

Every time someone tells me we can't have a huge college football playoff in the FBS, I point to this system, which is freaking awesome. It's an interesting system, where 24 teams make it, but 8 teams have "1st round" byes.

I want the FBS to have a full 64 team playoff, I want the regular season for every team to be 10 games (Colgate played 10, North Dakota St. played 11), and then maybe an 11th for a conference championship. Then put together a second, 64 team playoff NIT-type tournament for the schools that don't get in.

Anyway, if you aren't watching, try to tune in. It's really good football.

Edit: Actually, NDSU has won 6 of the last 7 National Championships, which is pretty amazing considering that besides Carson Wentz, they haven't had a ton of guys that went on NFL careers, or even guys who were the best players in the FCS that year.
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
73,070
Yes watching it, best thing on right now.

NDSU has depth and coaching. That's why they're great
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,027
Yes watching it, best thing on right now.

NDSU has depth and coaching. That's why they're great
They're almost ridiculous. Going into today, they are 109-8 since 2011. That's mind-boggling. And it's through 2 different head coaches. Craig Bohl was their coach until 2013, when he left after winning a third straight national championship, to go coach Wyoming. Then Chris Klieman took over, and they've won 3 in 4 years, and are rolling along to their 4th in 5. Klieman was brought in as the defensive coordinator (kind of out of the blue) in 2011, and helped Bohl basically turn the program into a juggernaut. They've really figured shit out down there.
 

mikeot

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2006
8,158
Funny how Army owns Navy now, after more than decade of Midshipman dominance just recently.
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,211
Not sure if any of you follow FCS football, but perennial powerhouse, and #1 seed in the playoffs, North Dakota State, is playing #8 Colgate right now on ESPN. It's pretty good stuff. Colgate comes in after beating another perennial power, James Madison. NDSU has won like 4 of the last 5 national championships.

Every time someone tells me we can't have a huge college football playoff in the FBS, I point to this system, which is freaking awesome. It's an interesting system, where 24 teams make it, but 8 teams have "1st round" byes.

I want the FBS to have a full 64 team playoff, I want the regular season for every team to be 10 games (Colgate played 10, North Dakota St. played 11), and then maybe an 11th for a conference championship. Then put together a second, 64 team playoff NIT-type tournament for the schools that don't get in.

Anyway, if you aren't watching, try to tune in. It's really good football.

Edit: Actually, NDSU has won 6 of the last 7 National Championships, which is pretty amazing considering that besides Carson Wentz, they haven't had a ton of guys that went on NFL careers, or even guys who were the best players in the FCS that year.
NDSU had far more talent than Colgate. It really wasn’t even close. Surprised they haven’t tried to make the jump to FBS given their stadium but they may be the equivalent of a AAAA team. That game wasn’t even remotely competitive and Colgate had a great year.

Looks like they have some FBS OOC games scheduled in the next 5 years, including at Oregon.
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,027
NDSU had far more talent than Colgate. It really wasn’t even close. Surprised they haven’t tried to make the jump to FBS given their stadium but they may be the equivalent of a AAAA team. That game wasn’t even remotely competitive and Colgate had a great year.

Looks like they have some FBS OOC games scheduled in the next 5 years, including at Oregon.
I think they'd be happy to schedule some OOC FBS games, but who would want to play them? If you're an FBS program, even a good one, what do you have to gain by playing North Dakota State and winning? Conversely, what do you have to lose if you don't win?

The reality is they are 5-0 against FBS opponents since they started this run, with the most notable victory coming when they walked into Iowa State 2 years ago, when Iowa was #13 in the country, and they beat them. They blew out Iowa State when they agreed to play them in their season opener, and beat Kansas State when they agreed to the same the year before. Colorado State and Minnesota are the other two victims.

There is a reason they haven't played FBS teams since 2016, and I'm pretty sure it has more to do with nobody wanting to play them than the other way around I'm happy that there are at least a couple schools willing to take the risk to play them in the next few years though.
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,211
I think they'd be happy to schedule some OOC FBS games, but who would want to play them? If you're an FBS program, even a good one, what do you have to gain by playing North Dakota State and winning? Conversely, what do you have to lose if you don't win?

The reality is they are 5-0 against FBS opponents since they started this run, with the most notable victory coming when they walked into Iowa State 2 years ago, when Iowa was #13 in the country, and they beat them. They blew out Iowa State when they agreed to play them in their season opener, and beat Kansas State when they agreed to the same the year before. Colorado State and Minnesota are the other two victims.

There is a reason they haven't played FBS teams since 2016, and I'm pretty sure it has more to do with nobody wanting to play them than the other way around I'm happy that there are at least a couple schools willing to take the risk to play them in the next few years though.
To be clear, I was being complimentary of the team. They looked really good. As a BC fan, I thought their QB is better than ours. But I also think they’re in no man’s land. They are going to win like their 7th title in 8 years. FCS teams can’t hang with them. So, if FBS teams won’t schedule them, then come to FBS. You’d think some conference would take them but maybe they’ve tried. Maybe they like to be the big fish in a small pond. Who knows.

We’ll see if SDSU can give them another good game.
 

h8mfy

New Member
Jul 15, 2005
336
Orange County, CA
I lean toward your take. They aren't in position to be stubborn and wait for a home-and-home series. They won't schedule a top program that way. Take your 2 for 1, win the games when they matter, and that will accomplish what they need to do. Go to the Swamp and win, and everyone will take them (more) seriously.
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,027
To be clear, I was being complimentary of the team. They looked really good. As a BC fan, I thought their QB is better than ours. But I also think they’re in no man’s land. They are going to win like their 7th title in 8 years. FCS teams can’t hang with them. So, if FBS teams won’t schedule them, then come to FBS. You’d think some conference would take them but maybe they’ve tried. Maybe they like to be the big fish in a small pond. Who knows.

We’ll see if SDSU can give them another good game.
I didn't think you were being derogatory towards them, I was just pointing out that they seem to try to schedule FBS schools, but there just isn't anyone willing to step up to the plate, and I kind of understand it from the perspective of the FBS schools.

I'd be curious to see what would happen if they moved up, but I don't know if it's a wise move. The stadium only holds like 19,000 people, so that isn't gonna cut it to get them into a top tier FBS conference, so it would have to probably be Conference USA or the Mid-American, and I'm not really sure getting into a conference that even if they dominated, they'd still be left out of the FBS playoffs. That said, I'm not sure they'd do as well. It can't be easy to recruit kids to come play in North Dakota, at least not kids who have other choices at the FBS level. I think they'll be like Mount Union in DIII, and just continue to dominate for years to come.
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,027
My God, who is this clown that can't read the year, 2018, that is going to announce the Heisman winner?
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,027
I would have voted for Haskins, but Kyler Murray takes down the Heisman. Pretty nice year for the kid, drafted by the A's, pockets $5million, wins the Heisman...Everything is coming up Kyler.
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
73,070
With Tessitore gone, no geographical breakdown, booooooo.

And by gone, I mean 10 blocks away.
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,211
I would have voted for Haskins, but Kyler Murray takes down the Heisman. Pretty nice year for the kid, drafted by the A's, pockets $5million, wins the Heisman...Everything is coming up Kyler.
The Charlie Ward model. Win Heisman. Make millions in another sport.
 

DukeSox

absence hasn't made the heart grow fonder
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2005
11,750
I would have voted for Haskins, but Kyler Murray takes down the Heisman. Pretty nice year for the kid, drafted by the A's, pockets $5million, wins the Heisman...Everything is coming up Kyler.
Minus the part about having to play for the A's.
 

Tangled Up In Red

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Nov 8, 2004
4,542
Potrero
I think UCF should take the 2 for 1s when they can get them. Win enough of those games and the whining about how unfair the rankings are will have more merit.
Ahh, the Boise State approach.
Still doesn't work.
There is always, always, the counter-argument. "Play better teams (but we won't let you in our conference)"
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
24,616
I know past teams aren't present teams, so UCF's two straight undefeated seasons (let's assume for fun they win their bowl game) don't have any real bearing on next year's team. But if they do win this year's bowl game against a big-time program and finish unbeaten again, at some point national pollsters doing the playoff rankings need to think, you know, I don't care that they're in a crappy conference...whoever they play, they beat, even when it's big-time power 5 schools in bowl games.

Or...maybe not.

And I couldn't really care less about UCF - it's not about them specifically for me. It's about any school in this situation. Even if they took the 2-1 situation and kept beating those teams, they're still not going to get into the playoff because their conference schedule is so weak comparatively, and there's nothing they can do about that unless a power 5 conference lets them in - which they won't.
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
73,070
They're almost ridiculous. Going into today, they are 109-8 since 2011. That's mind-boggling. And it's through 2 different head coaches. Craig Bohl was their coach until 2013, when he left after winning a third straight national championship, to go coach Wyoming. Then Chris Klieman took over, and they've won 3 in 4 years, and are rolling along to their 4th in 5. Klieman was brought in as the defensive coordinator (kind of out of the blue) in 2011, and helped Bohl basically turn the program into a juggernaut. They've really figured shit out down there.
Another epic beatdown.

 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,027
Another epic beatdown.

Yep, and as usual, they find a new way to get it done today. Their QB, Easton Stick (great name, by the way), who is a capable runner, but not a great one, went off today for 147 yards and 3tds' on 14 carries. As a team, they ran for 439 yards, and ended up winning 44-21 against South Dakota State.

In the other semifinal game, Eastern Washington rolled Maine 50-19. Eastern Washington has a ridiculously high powered offense, and they have for years. Their quarterback, Erik Barriere threw for 352 yards and 7td's today. Barriere is their backup QB, who took over for Gabe Gubrud in September after Gubrud hurt his foot. Gubrud was a two time finalist for the Walter Payton award coming into this season and he set the FCS record for passing yards in a season as a sophomore with 5,160, so he was a huge loss, and they haven't missed a beat. EWU is the same school that produced Cooper Kupp who holds every college football receiving record and plays for the Rams, and the receiver opposite him was Kendrick Bourne, who plays for the Niners now. Their top receiver this year is Nsimba Webster, who had over 180 yards and 4td's today. Bottom line, they can score with anyone, and should be able to move the ball against NDSU, but NDSU usually figures out a way to slow teams like this down just a little bit, while exploding for 40+ themselves. Either way, should be a good game, at least for a while.
 

The Napkin

wise ass al kaprielian
Moderator
SoSH Member
Jul 13, 2002
28,614
right here
Down 21-20 with 2 minutes left Ga Southern converts with about a 30 yard play on 4th and 10 to the EMU 30. They slow things down and only run 2 plays, leaving the ball on the 25 with 2 seconds left for a game winning 42-yard field goal attempt.
Guess what happens next.