Craig Carton in talks for MLB Network morning show


SoSH Member
Dec 4, 2009
WFAN host Craig Carton is in talks with MLB Network to host a daily morning TV show, The Post has learned.

Whether or not a deal goes through, Carton, who was released from federal prison last year following a conviction for fraud, would continue to do his afternoon drive-time show on WFAN with Evan Roberts.
Carton, 52, still owes the victims of his crime nearly $5 million.

The potential Carton MLBN show would be a one-hour program, a source said.

MLB Network has had success in early afternoons with SiriusXM and former WFAN host Christopher (Mad Dog) Russo. Carton, though, is a different type of host than Russo.

While Russo is not going to lead the league in getting every fact right, he is an entertaining baseball savant. Carton, on the other hand, is more into personal potshots than knowing the ins and outs of the game.

He recently called ESPN MLB insider Jeff Passan, a “weasel” after Passan and Mina Kimes broke the story about Mets GM Jared Porter’s harassing texts that ended up costing Porter his job. seems like something MLB Network will end up regretting. That’s not even talking about his legal issues which should have been the end of talks from the start.


Jan 20, 2013
Drexel Hill Pa.
He was also sued by Eric Lindros and the Flyers when he was in Philly on the air saying that Lindros missed a game in Feb. of 1997 because he was hungover, not an injury as reported by the Flyers. They settled the next year when Inifinity Broadcasting who owned station WIP donated money to a charity.
Last edited:


SoSH Member
Dec 7, 2008
Chris Russo is a baseball savant?

I'm sure Carton will say a bunch of really dumb shit and get people talking because HOT TAKES are what apparently what people want to hear in 2021


SoSH Member
Feb 12, 2003
where I was last at
I listen to Carton and Evan Roberts from time to time and Carton is clearly the alpha. I kind of wonder about the long-term prospects of that team as it does not really showcase Robert's solid sports knowledge. Carton's funny and entertaining but he doesn't know much about baseball, nor does he strike me as a big fan of the game.

Philip Jeff Frye

SoSH Member
Oct 23, 2001
I find him hard to listen to. He's too into goofing around and being obnoxious versus talking about actual sports. It worked okay, and often quite well, in a morning show format but buffoonery is not what I'm looking for an afternoon sports talk show. Boomer Esiason had the ability to stop him from getting out of control, but Evans Roberts doesn't, and Roberts often seems like he's unable to get a word in edgewise, let alone talk about actual sports. It's a waste of his talent.


Well-Known Member
Silver Supporter
SoSH Member
Jan 23, 2009

I don't know anything about the guy other than what I've read here (including his legal issues), but if they're using Russo as the measuring stick for what makes good content and are landing on this guy as a result, I'm out. Russo is far and away the most unwatchable/unlistenable person on MLB Network. His is the only show I avoid at all costs. There have been many days where I've put on the channel in the morning and kept it there all day...except for his show.

And so help me if this proposed show cuts into their 10 hour block of Quick Pitch...
Jul 18, 2019
One of the most loathsome people in sports media. I don’t know why MLB Network would do this over hiring people who aren’t repugnant people, they could just keep reairing Quick Pitch and be just fine.