“I think playing him on Saturday was a mistake by everybody involved,” he said.
Youkilis has been battling back pain since April 19 in Toronto. He missed seven games before he told Girardi on Saturday that he was healed and ready to play. But after that game the pain returned, and because he played the Yankees could not backdate his placement on the D.L. to April 20, the day after he was originally injured. If they had, he would have been eligible to come off the D.L. on Sunday. Now he will not be eligible to return until May 13.
Equally important as his eligibility date was that Youkilis was not ready to play, and that may have led to him reinjuring the back while making a diving tag at first base.
“His facial expression from that point on, I was like, ‘We’re going to have a problem,’ ” Cashman said. “And we did.”
Girardi was asked if he would now have to ask Youkilis twice before believing that he was healthy.
“I might ask him six more times,” Girardi said.