The Phillies entertained various scenarios for their outfield and it was not until after the lockout ended — and new rules were revealed — that they
veered toward a platoon between
Matt Vierling and
Odúbel Herrera for center field. The team engaged Tampa Bay about a trade for
Kevin Kiermaier before the lockout, according to multiple sources. The Phillies were willing to assume most of Kiermaier’s money for a marginal prospect return. Kiermaier would have been a massive defensive upgrade for the Phillies, although he would have come with questions about his durability and performance at the plate.
The calculus changed with the new collective bargaining agreement. A small accounting wrinkle to contracts that are traded had a direct effect on a player like Kiermaier. He is signed to a six-year, $53 million deal, which means his average annual value is $8.83 million. However, under the new CBA, a traded contract is recalculated to reflect the remaining actual dollars. That means contracts that are backloaded will be harder to trade (if the acquiring team is concerned about the luxury tax threshold).
Had the Phillies acquired Kiermaier in a trade, he would have counted for $14.67 million against the luxury tax payroll in 2022. That number might have prevented the Phillies — operating on a budget designed not to pay tax — from other moves. They did not value Kiermaier at that rate, along with whatever prospect capital it would have cost. So, they explored other options for center field.