My screen name comes from how I imagine Mark Gemelli talking about the Celtics (in retrospect I wish I went with Al Waffid), so I'd like to think my criticism comes from a place of love. This is my favorite radio show.
I mean I can hate on Rich too - like sometimes I can hear the back of his throat. I especially notice when he does it on "...the rangellllhhhhhh" but once you hear it there you hear it in places you don't want to, like sometimes when he laughs or just enunciates things a certain way. Other than Fred's sporadic and unexpected absences I think the show is consistently better in the last year than it's ever been...or maybe it's just I've become parasocially codependent on these guys.
My favorite bit is brookline 911. I really enjoy segments like the one a couple weeks ago when they were bagging on Megadeth ("Whattya mean I hoit ya feelings? didn't know ya had any! Ha cha cha!") and in general when they're talking about music they're better and more fun than anyone except maybe Harvilla (I love the Sound Opinions guys but the show is as much fun as a homework assignment). I also really like when Fred gets into the history of radio and things he's experienced on the other side of the mic and like how misguided consultants are with the whole "guys like gadgets and dames" stuff.
My favorite part of their sports talk is easily when they hate on Matt Patricia. I also like the Finebaum stuff and the new Syracuse Boys bit Rich is doing. I don't like when they try the more traditional sports talk stuff like this morning when Rich was saying Mazzula is bad because he plays Tatum too much as though it's not obvious why he has to do it. I can get sportsing done better from Felger and Callahan in the afternoons.
I have been flying regularly for probably 35 years and the one time I have ever seen someone removed from a flight it was because she was catatonic. My read on the situation, given the frankly embarrassing amount of time I spend listening to the show, is that Fred is probably the one who had the panic attack. It seems to me like he felt entitled to something that belonged to someone else (regardless of his reasons) and when he didn't get it he threw a full-on tantrum and got himself tossed. If his daughter were uncomfortable and he made an honest attempt at modeling calmness and restraint (it's a lot to ask of anyone, I know, but bear with me here) he probably could have put her at ease, and if not, they could have left the plane voluntarily.
There are two reasons things like this really suck. For one, it hurts the integrity of the show when their most talented guy is unreliable like this, like I don't know how much longer they can keep it together. The other is more personal. I used to be able to empathize with Fred's rants - like I said, I loved when he went off on EEi after they took the #1 rating - but lately there have been a lot of things where I'm thinking "what is wrong with this guy? Isn't he a grown man?" Using this situation as an example: like you're going to tell us how much you hate when people disrupt flights, like just sit down! and shut up!...but it's OK for me to do you know you just have to understand my situation please agree with me! Look at literally the first post in this thread. This guy hasn't figured anything out in almost 14 years and he wants us to feel sorry for him? Imagine if Crash demanded we take him seriously.
And NEPJ I'm sorry...I'm sorry. If things were fine I'd just be merrily lurking like always but I had to make an account and get this off my chest. I don't live in Boston so you guys are the only ones I can talk to about this. If it's bothering me this much I imagine other longtime fans are starting to feel the same unease that I am. Otherwise if I come across as a mere hater, I hope I come across as a diligent and hard-working hater.