I watch my fair share of Yankees games being in NY and from my experience the YES crew have no problem criticizing the team when they do poorly. Kay and the rotating analysts are critical of the team when they need to be and there's no crying from the clubhouse.
Well, yes and no. Singleton and O'Neil are out and out homers that match Remy and Harrelson . The rest do their share of criticism when called for, although there are certain untouchables, namely Cc and Jeter , but some of the kids look like they are on the list too.
Also, the Yankees only own 20% of Yes, not 80% like the Red Sox do NESN. Its a 2 team town as well, so some portion of their audience is not Yankee fans and criticism is more tolerated and even expected as the press and radio talk shows are loyal to no team. Not like WEEI, Globe and NESN which are either majority owned by the Red Sox and/or financially dependent on the team with few real competitors
It depends on what you call criticism as well. Pointing out some unpleasant facts , or mentioning that certain stats are unpleasant is simply telling the truth and not criticism IMO. Eck simply stated E-rods stat line was yucky. Thats not criticism even if the stats dont mean much (neither do a good statline for a given game)
Eck has mellowed the last couple of years. He used to be far more critical. I felt he had been asked to tone things down long ago and has complied, which may be a reason he does not feel welcome in the clubhouse even before Price. The old Eck was much more entertaining although I have to admit I am watching the other teams feed more often since Orsillo left.
I guess we are lucky Price did not bring race into it. Frankly, it is a bit overblown. Ecks probably been told off by tougher guys than Price and most of us get treated far worse by airline staff and TSA. I kind of think Price keeps his yap shut if Gomes says yuck next time he gives up 6 runs.