Drew Brees has won one Super Bowl. Aaron Rodgers has one. Russ Wilson has one. Even though pretty much all of us expect more, Patrick Mahomes has one. Peyton Manning won one when he was a great QB and a second as a bad QB because he had an historically great defense.
Everything is definitely easier with a great QB, no question. But winning a Super Bowl remains hard for everyone... except Tom Brady.
It's interesting to look back on the QB's whose teams were eliminated by Brady in the playoffs. All total, 27 QB's were eliminated at the arm of Brady; theoretically, each one could argue that they had a Super Bowl chance taken away by Brady. In some cases (Tim Tebow), that argument would not hold much water. But there are clearly some really good QB's and future HoF'ers that have less Super Bowl rings than they probably would have otherwise thanks to Brady:
QB's where Brady directly cost them a ring, by virtue of losing the SB:
Kurt Warner: Only 1 Super Bowl Ring in his HoF career
Jake Delhomme
Donovan McNabb: 6x Pro-Bowler that never sniffed the SB again
Russell Wilson: 1 and counting
Matt Ryan: Future HoF'er denied a ring
Jared Goff
Patrick Mahomes
QB's who were denied a SB appearance by Brady in the AFCCG or NFCCG:
Kordell Stewart: Steelers probably would have lost to the Rams.
Peyton Manning: Suck it! But the Colts would likely have handled the Panthers in a close game.
Ben Roethlisberger (2x): May have beaten a wounded Eagles team or the imperfect Falcons for a 3rd or even 4th ring
Philip Rivers: Would have been an all-time upset in the AFCCG, but the Chargers played the Pats right to the end, and Brady was hurt after the game. May have beaten the Giants in what would have been his first and only SB appearence.
Joe Flacco: That Ravens team may have handled the Giants more easily than the wounded Pats, giving Flacco 2 rings.
Andrew Luck: Probably would have lost to the Seahawks, but a talented QB never got back to the conference championship game.
Blake Bortles: If he makes a Super Bowl, it will probably be as the holder on the field goal unit.
Mahomes: KC would likley have shredded LA. 0-2 in the playoffs against TB12.
Aaron Rodgers: Will he get another shot at it?
Earlier round eliminations:
Rich Gannon: That Raiders team was pretty good, but doubtful they would have beaten the Rams had they gotten by the Steelers
Steve McNair: The co-MVP whose team was 1 yard short never made it back to the Big Game. Titans would have had a chance against both Colts and Panthers.
Peyton Manning: NFL changes the rules, and Peyton still loses. Would have had to beat Steelers and Eagles.
Byron Leftwich: He can tell his grandchildren that he won a Super Bowl coaching Brady. But he did win 2 rings as a backup to Big Ben.
Chad Pennington: He can tell his grandchildren that he beat Brady twice over his career. May not want to mention the 7 losses.
Philip Rivers (2x): Went 0-3 against Brady in the playoffs. 2006 most likely cost him ring; 2018 would have been more difficult w/ the Chiefs in the way.
David Garrard (2x): 1-2 career playoff record, with both losses against Brady.
Tim Tebow: His reward for that highlight reel pass to beat the Steelers was a matchup against Brady in his final playoff game.
Joe Flacco: The only QB not named Manning to beat Brady more than once in the playoffs. Should have been able to fend off the Colts; tossup if they beat Seattle.
Matt Schaub: Got to the SB as a backup, and thought his ring was secure once the Tevin Coleman caught that pass from Ryan.
Andrew Luck: Luck's Colts had 4 playoff runs, 2 cut short by Brady.
Alex Smith: Beat Brady in a regular season blowout once.
Brock Osweiler: Those Houston teams always came up short.
Marcus Mariota: Surprise upset of the Chiefs was rewarded with a courtesy appearance against Brady in Foxboro. Got revenge as a backup where he threw 1 pass.
Blake Bortles: Seems likely that his next appearance in a SB will be as a backup.
Taylor Heinicke: Something to tell his kids and grandkids, after he acquitted himself well.
Drew Brees: Saints probably were not good enough to beat either Packers or Chiefs.