reggiecleveland said:
And now this? He looked good in one session in February. We knew he had great stuff. This is not new, he will have days he looks awesome. This is just a "best shape of his life" story.
I agree. That story read like one of hundreds others over the years covering hundreds of other gifted, but incomplete pitchers, (Clay Buchholz being the most recent Red Sox version). For me, the telling quote was by Napoli: “He has a really good fastball. He just needs to be able to locate it. He’s got a good curveball and changeup. Of the five starters, he might have the best stuff of everybody. He’s just got to put it together.” Locating the fastball is what separates the elite from the average. "Putting it together" is a polite way of saying "if he can ever live up to his promise."
That said, and as we've seen with Clay, things can click, even for half a season or so. Hell, it even clicked for Kelly himself with the Cardinals in 2013 — going 9-3 with a 2.28 ERA in 15 starts.
On the plus side, everything I've heard about him is that like Gomes or Millar or Peavy, he has plus-plus-locker room chemistry intangibles. I wasn't in the least bit surprised to see the picture of him and Hanley mugging for the camera over the HBP from a couple years back.