Mayo is the New Coach

Gash Prex

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 18, 2002
6,867
Pretty exciting to hear Mayo might have helped finally look like we have a clue against Josh Allen

Mayo’s also acted as the Patriots defacto-defensive coordinator. Following a standout defensive effort against the Buffalo Bills, Deatrich Wise credited Mayo for the team’s game plan in shutting down Josh Allen. The coach’s duties include breaking down the opponent’s offense, game planning on how to stop them, and breaking down practice and film sessions to give players their corrections.
 

GPO Man

New Member
Apr 1, 2023
571
Wow players and former players seems to LOVE this. One after another popping up with glowing support on Twitter

View attachment 76481
One of my old managers used to say that if employees are overly excited about a new boss, it’s probably because they know they will be easy to work for. I’m not suggesting Mayo will be a pushover, but the players don’t want a new guy coming in telling them what to do. Especially post-Belichick.
 

dcdrew10

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
1,402
Washington, DC via Worcester
Positives for Mayo:
  • He had a major hand in the only functional unit on the team and the players in that unit want to work for him
  • People view his intelligence/curiosity and communication skills as strengths
  • He seems like the type of guy who knows what he doesn't know and I hope that translates to hiring practices, especially on the offense and special teams side
  • I think he's got enough BB in him, with the ability to better connect with the more modern players
  • He came up under BB
Negatives are mostly his unknowns/inexperience:
  • Hasn't been a HC
  • Hasn't called defensive plays during a regular season game
  • We don't know how he will hire or be involved with the offense
  • He came up under BB
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
73,437
Hope he can find some mustard for the offense!
LFG surprise people in 24 (in a good way)
 

singaporesoxfan

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 21, 2004
11,889
Washington, DC
THIS speaks volumes to me. We've got ONE PERSON in our org who deals with data. We are WAY behind the times. MIller wears WAY too many hats and can't possibly innovate when he's responsible for the cap, finances and player analytics.

Specifically, what worries me more than the number of analysts is that Richard Miller is in charge of both analytics and finances (apparently his duties include managing the salary cap and player costs, contract research and statistical trends, financial and strategic planning, and assisting the personnel department with draft, free agency and game advance analytics). Those are two separate skill sets and full-time areas of research, even if they are quantitative, and even if ultimately they can roll up to one AGM.
 

Al Zarilla

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
59,354
San Andreas Fault
Just a light bit to post here; on Good Morning Football, they had Jason McCourty, a regular on the show speak first and he had all the usual good stuff to say about Mayo. Then, Kyle Brandt said (paraphrasing) that they've gone from a 24 year genius guy but with Ebenezer Scrooge traits to a more ebullient guy, etc., etc. Brandt is always good for funny stuff.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,935
Positives for Mayo:
  • He had a major hand in the only functional unit on the team and the players in that unit want to work for him
  • People view his intelligence/curiosity and communication skills as strengths
  • He seems like the type of guy who knows what he doesn't know and I hope that translates to hiring practices, especially on the offense and special teams side
  • I think he's got enough BB in him, with the ability to better connect with the more modern players
  • He came up under BB
Negatives are mostly his unknowns/inexperience:
  • Hasn't been a HC
  • Hasn't called defensive plays during a regular season game
  • We don't know how he will hire or be involved with the offense
  • He came up under BB
I believe he has been calling plays at least part time the last 2 years according to various articles

Edit- also not sure it would matter, many head coaches don't call plays, in fact not sure I would expect Mayo to depending who he puts at DC
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,092

I wrote this here in November, 2021:

https://sonsofsamhorn.net/index.php?threads/lets-say-bb-stays-on-until-he-retires-what-does-that-mean-for-the-franchise.34882/page-8#post-4741688

"I think I've told this story before. I had a chance, via a charity auction to spend hours in the stadium with Matthew Slater, and a couple other players. The culmination was a movie night on the field jumbotron, with about 30 friends (including kids). We got to see the entire locker room, including the weight room.

On the wall of the weight room, they have a bunch of "awards" on a wall. Things like highest bench press, etc. But they also had their "offseason player of the year" stuff. That wall and every award could have been renamed the Jerod Mayo Wall of Fame, because the guy seemingly won every offseason conditioning award, and everything else on top of it. One of the players said Bill handpicked those awards himself every year. My only thought when looking at the wall was "Wow, Bill fucking loves Jerod Mayo." When Mayo was brought back to be on the coaching staff, it was the least surprising move he's ever made, IMO.

Mayo will be an NFL head coach before he's 40. Mark it down."


This is the least surprising thing ever. Pats knew they were doing this, which is why it was put into Mayo's contract last season, and got them around the Rooney Rule with this hire. They wanted him locked up, because if he didn't get the job this year, Mayo would be a head coach somewhere else this season. They got their man, now let's see if it works.
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,092
Those sources also claim Mayo was a long shot to replace Bill.
Bedard is a troll.

If those sources knew anything, they'd have known that Mayo's last contract included a provision that he would be the next head coach of the Pats. It's literally the only way they could have hired him without interviewing from outside the organization to satisfy the Rooney Rule.

"The Patriots wrote into his contract last January that Mayo would succeed Belichick as the next head coach. Because they communicated with the league that this clause existed, the Patriots were not required to conduct a full coaching search following the Rooney Rule, which typically requires teams to conduct in-person interviews with at least two external minority candidates. Mayo becomes the first Black non-interim head coach for the Patriots."

https://theathletic.com/5198294/2024/01/12/jerod-mayo-hiring-patriots-head-coach/
 
Oct 12, 2023
720
One advantage Mayo has is that he probably has some insight into the other coaches on the staff.


There are other similar ones floating around as well.

I think the "offensive minded" HC is way overrated, as compared to who is the OC in '24. Somehow "offensive minded" head coaches around the league manage to field teams with good defenses. As for inexperience, I suppose that's a real thing. But in recent - and not so recent -- years, the likes of McVay and Tomlin have done pretty well.
And in the NFL, "experience" is often a proxy for "mediocre re-tread." Not always. Just like HC experience is Not always determinative.
the argument for “offensive minded HC” is closely tied to the idea that a young QB (which the Pats badly need) benefits from stability on offense. If the Pats get a great OC who works well with their 3rd overall pick QB and then that OC leaves the next year, it creates problems for the young QB. Whereas if your HC is the brains behind the offense, you can keep coach and QB together for as long as those guys are succeeding.
 
Oct 12, 2023
720
One thing this definitely (as far as we know) was not was "rushed". This plan has been in place for a long time and they're obviously very, very comfortable with Mayo as the HC. And that gives me confidence. They've done well hiring front office people.
Other than Bill, who was not really hired to be a “front office person”, who has Kraft hired that indicates he’s “done well”? Bobby Grier?
 

67YAZ

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2000
8,832
Specifically, what worries me more than the number of analysts is that Richard Miller is in charge of both analytics and finances (apparently his duties include managing the salary cap and player costs, contract research and statistical trends, financial and strategic planning, and assisting the personnel department with draft, free agency and game advance analytics). Those are two separate skill sets and full-time areas of research, even if they are quantitative, and even if ultimately they can roll up to one AGM.
A lot of the staffing budget will open up if Bill takes another job. He was reportedly making $20m a year. The NFL average for head coaches is ~$6.5m. Mayo has some leverage as the named successor, but is also a first time head coach. Let's say he makes about what Saleh and LaFleur make - $5m. So that's $15m in savings minus whatever remains after Bill's offset.

They should plow that savings back into front office staff, including analytics , as well as quality control staff. (Yesterday, Breer wrote about how there were no QC staff on the offensive side, which was a huge drain on the staff. Seems insane that these positions went unfilled.)
 
Last edited:

snowmanny

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
15,776
I wish they -- the Krafts -- had had a plan for a big-brained GM hire who would then, as the actual football nerd, hire a coach.

I hope Mayo coaches the team from now until the end of time, but it seems like a quick move with the order of operations off.
What GM has a proven track record of hiring coaches that is better than Kraft’s record?
 

Mystic Merlin

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 21, 2007
47,044
Hartford, CT
Bedard is a troll.

If those sources knew anything, they'd have known that Mayo's last contract included a provision that he would be the next head coach of the Pats. It's literally the only way they could have hired him without interviewing from outside the organization to satisfy the Rooney Rule.

"The Patriots wrote into his contract last January that Mayo would succeed Belichick as the next head coach. Because they communicated with the league that this clause existed, the Patriots were not required to conduct a full coaching search following the Rooney Rule, which typically requires teams to conduct in-person interviews with at least two external minority candidates. Mayo becomes the first Black non-interim head coach for the Patriots."

https://theathletic.com/5198294/2024/01/12/jerod-mayo-hiring-patriots-head-coach/
I can imagine Mayo - who is already rich, super confident and ambitious, and was anointed by Kraft within three years or so of joining the staff - would breed some resentment among members of the staff. Too bad. Given how vague Bedard’s report was (he doesn’t explain how he ‘rubbed people the wrong way’), and I said this at the time Bedard dropped it, it’s a chickenshit bit of reporting.
 

Ralphwiggum

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 27, 2012
9,837
Needham, MA
Kyle has pretty clearly proven himself to be a good coach on his own. Steve B. should want to do the same, and if he's truly a good coach he'll show it out from under his Dad's shadow. Technically he could do that by staying in NE under Mayo but I think both he and Mayo would be better off with a clean break from the Belichick name in New England. Just my opinion obviously.
 

joe dokes

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
30,614
Other than Bill, who was not really hired to be a “front office person”, who has Kraft hired that indicates he’s “done well”? Bobby Grier?
Maybe Kraft should sell to an owner who has hired lots of people. Dan Snyder has hired lots of people. And he's available.
 

OurF'ingCity

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 22, 2016
8,469
New York City
So we’re basically following the Texans path here - hire a young defensive minded coach with no previous HC experience and hope for a quick turnaround. That worked out pretty well for the Texans.

Of course, the single biggest factor in the Texans’ turnaround was that they nailed their QB pick. Remains to be seen if the Pats can do the same.
 

RSN Diaspora

molests goats for comedy
SoSH Member
Jul 29, 2005
11,430
Washington, DC
Both James White and Jason McCourty are ecstatic over the Mayo hire on Twitter, FWIW.
Wow players and former players seems to LOVE this. One after another popping up with glowing support on Twitter
One of my old managers used to say that if employees are overly excited about a new boss, it’s probably because they know they will be easy to work for. I’m not suggesting Mayo will be a pushover, but the players don’t want a new guy coming in telling them what to do. Especially post-Belichick.
Not to pick on any one of you, but current players have already worked under Mayo and former players will generally applaud a big promotion for a former teammate of theirs. I like the hire, and obviously their support for the move can be rooted in multiple factors, including how good they think he'll be, but I'm not sure there's a whole lot to be taken from their applause.
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
18,244
Bold move that I love! The problem with the team this past season was not, for the most part, the coaching, it was the personnel. So am happy that they valued the continuity; seems like the type that will make players want to through a wall for him.

Lack of prior HC experience can cut either way. I personally am interested to see what a brand new HC can bring. I know posters have raised the topics of the sizes of the staff and the analytics groups under Bill. My guess is that the sizes of the Pats staff were probably typical when Bill was climbing the coaching ranks, and Bill just didn't see the need to add more. Doesn't mean Bill was wrong, but perhaps the reports of Bill becoming more insular had a grain of truth to them, and so am hopeful that Mayo can start putting together a strong staff with a mix of young, innovative coaches and some veteran hands.

And, again, fuck Greg Bedard for publishing that nonsense piece amplifying the grumblings of a petty assistant. Classic example of why Bill never wanted to "play nice" with the media, because they will turn around and burn your ass regardless.

We're on to Secaucus.... ;)
 

WayneHousieHOF

wants you to hate boston teams like him
SoSH Member
Jan 13, 2004
693
295 corridor
That is fair. But, it is clear that the move was not rushed. There was a succession plan in place and Kraft executed it.

GM is next. Then figure out OC and the remaining staff.

With the state of the defense, a top 3 pick, and the cap space, I doubt we see anything close to the early 90s redux of multiple 2-15, 3-14, 4-13 seasons.
So, agreed, it is a good idea to see the other dominos that fall here. Get a GM. Get an OC.
See big picture.

I still think it’s going to be a tough job for any incoming GM with an owner’s hand-picked coach in place. That’s not completely ideal and I wonder if that will give any potential candidates pause.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,935
ok, so some of the PFF guys were talking about OC options for Chicago and a FASCINATING name came up I never considered......

Kliff Kingsbury. He was a pretty good playcaller, has a long history of QB development... he's a bad HC. Would be interesting as a way to get a guy to pair with your young QB and he's less likely to get poached by another team after 1 year.
 

BusRaker

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 11, 2006
2,379
As much I hate even the sight of mayonaisse (on french fries, really France?) I'm excited about this move. The fact that Bob is going with the status quo in the coaching room makes me think that the parting was solely based on the GM responsibilities. I'm glad the Krafts didn't clean house although I think Mayo needs to do so on the offense and special teams coaching groups. Sorry BOB. Looking forward to JM on the sidelines
 

jsinger121

@jsinger121
SoSH Member
Jul 25, 2005
17,697
As much I hate even the sight of mayonaisse (on french fries, really France?) I'm excited about this move. The fact that Bob is going with the status quo in the coaching room makes me think that the parting was solely based on the GM responsibilities. I'm glad the Krafts didn't clean house although I think Mayo needs to do so on the offense and special teams coaching groups. Sorry BOB. Looking forward to JM on the sidelines
No thanks on McDaniels. Go with someone with a better offense.
 

Bigdogx

New Member
Jul 21, 2020
166
Boston media already resetting their focus on ownership when this move fails and Bill moves on and has success elsewhere. Then it will be first you let Brady leave, then you let Bill walk...

On the drive in they were already discussing how this move was probably the most financially feasible move to make.. I hope Bob realizes he is setting himself up for a lot of bad press, and this press will be hungry for someone to kick since Bill is no longer around if it goes south! With this roster i dont see good things ahead.
 

jtn46

Member
SoSH Member
Oct 10, 2004
9,775
Norwalk, CT
Just because he was coached by and worked for Belichick doesn’t mean he has the same philosophies on offense, defense, personnel, etc… He’s young and intelligent, I’m sure he understands that immobile pocket passers are out of fashion unless you have an elite offensive line like the Niners. I would have been excited about Vrabel but I can see the possibility that Mayo is more of a departure from Belichick than Vrabel would have been.

They obviously loved Mayo and have seen him as the HC for the future for awhile and I’m excited to see why. I know people are fretting over a defense-minded HC but having a good defense is still very important and we would be lucky if Mayo can maintain that strength of the Pats.
 

joe dokes

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
30,614
On the drive in they were already discussing how this move was probably the most financially feasible move to make.. I hope Bob realizes he is setting himself up for a lot of bad press, and this press will be hungry for someone to kick since Bill is no longer around if it goes south! With this roster i dont see good things ahead.
Really? Are they implying that the cost played even a minor role? (I doubt it). They dont think Kraft could have found someone cheaper than Mayo? (He could have).
If he cared *that* much about bad press, he would not have hired Belichick in the first place.
 

Harry Hooper

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jan 4, 2002
34,615
I don't think it's fair to characterize Bedard's story and related comments about Mayo as negative or trolling, but YMMV. Bedard preferred a more experienced person taking the reins, which is not a radical take.

From Dec. 14th (see last sentence):

- While nearly everyone I've talked to believes Mayo has the stuff to be a head coach, I can't find many who believe he is ready to assume that role right now. He needs to sit and learn more from a coach who shares a bit more, like a Vrabel, and to have more responsibility. Of course, if Mayo is passed over, you can almost guarantee he'll re-enter the HC interview circuit.

- Multiple team sources indicated Mayo has rubbed at least some people the wrong way in the building since his extension and when he, perhaps, received a strong indication he would be the successor (the idea was more for 2025 or '26). Maybe this is of no concern to the Krafts, if their mind was already made up. I have no new information that would lead me to believe the Krafts don't continue to think highly of Mayo. But you would expect them to do their due diligence on whoever they might have in mind — internal or external. Of course, you can't rule out that some sources are lining up their own boats and perhaps thinking that Mayo may be setting a new course.
 

j44thor

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
11,118
It is worth noting NE thought highly enough of Mayo that they didn't even let him interview last year which would have netted them a 3rd rd pick had he been hired by another team. Or perhaps Mayo declined all interviews after they adjusted his contract either way they mutually decided he was worth more than a 3rd rd pick which is saying something.
 

Deathofthebambino

Drive Carefully
SoSH Member
Apr 12, 2005
42,092
The idea that BB doesn't believe in analytics isn't really true. Ernie Adams was very much an analytics guy, and he put that stuff in front of BB all the time.

https://www.espn.com/espn/eticket/story?page=adams&redirected=true

Or there's Rutgers statistics professor Harold Sackrowitz, who got a call from Adams a few years back. Adams wanted to talk about some research Sackrowitz had just completed, dealing with how teams try two-point conversions far too often. Adams sent the professor the Patriots' when-to-go-for-two chart, and asked Sackrowitz to tear it apart. Of the 32 NFL teams, the statistician told the New York Times, only the Patriots called.

Here's another example: The academic paper of a Berkeley researcher, referenced in the same Times story, dealt with how teams punt on fourth down far too often. That paper ended up on Belichick's desk. Now, how do you imagine it got there?

On game day, Adams wears a headset in the press box, a direct line to Belichick. Adams advises Belichick on which plays to challenge, and charts trends. "The one thing the Patriots do better than anyone else is they adjust and make halftime adjustments," Sturges says. "Ernie Adams is the guy who does that."




And Ernie had a hand in one of SoSH's favorites, Friday Night Lights:

In the broadest definition, Adams seems to be a man who loves to be in the background of greatness. Many things have his fingerprints on them, such as the game plan that engineered the upset of the Rams in Super Bowl XXXVI. Yes, Adams and Belichick figured out how to neutralize Marshall Faulk on the plane ride to New Orleans. Adams is involved in a lot of surprising things; he's a kind of "Forrest Gump" of sporting success. Like, say, the best-selling book "Friday Night Lights," which documented high school football, and later became a movie and a television show. That's right. "I'm indebted to him because he really turned me on to Odessa, Texas," says author Buzz Bissinger, who went to Andover with Adams and Belichick.


Losing Ernie, BB's best friend, I think is the most underrated loss in the organization over the last 4-5 years.
 

Justthetippett

New Member
Aug 9, 2015
2,511
I'm excited to see how Mayo manages the football operation, engages with the media, engages with the personnel department, etc. That's a huge part of his job. He can delegate offense, defense, game prep, etc. (which is why I am less worried about his defensive past, as long as he brings in an appropriate OC) but he has to manage. It sounds like he excels in this area, or at least that's what we've heard. Let's see how he does as the big boss and when things get tough. It's going to be a big challenge for him
 

joe dokes

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
30,614
I don't think it's fair to characterize Bedard's story and related comments about Mayo as negative or trolling, but YMMV. Bedard preferred a more experienced person taking the reins, which is not a radical take.

From Dec. 14th (see last sentence):
"He needs to sit and learn" is such patronizing garbage.