I was one of the folks whose seats were destroyed by the new club. My friends father originally bought two separate sets of 2 seats going back to Harvard Stadium. I bought a pair from him about 20 years ago, and have been buying them every season since, so they are effectively my seats (my buddy's father has since passed, so the tickets are now in my friend's name as they can't be transferred to non-family). Over the course of many, many years, my seats were upgraded many times, until they were finally located in the third row of section 123, which was basically in the corner of the end zone. They were also seats 1 and 2, which gave me an aisle seat, something I cherish.
When the plans were released, I got an email with the offer outlined in the letter (option to get lounge membership, etc.) and a list of "comparable" seats that I could choose from, or seats in better sections that I could upgrade to. I ended up choosing to stay in the same price point, and ended up two sections over in 125, row 6, seats 1 and 2. I wish I had done a bit more homework, because I didn't realize that in that section, seats 1 and 2 are in the middle of the row, and not on the aisle, which fucking blows, but all in all, I can't say that they didn't provide me options to get seats that were as good or better. There were tons of options. I was also given a parking pass for every game this season (a value of about $500) at no cost.
This club will have absolutely zero affect on noise. As someone else said, the lack of noise in the stadium has much more to do with the fact that the other end of the stadium is open than anything else, and this won't affect that at all. I also very much disagree with the contention that it's as quiet as television would suggest. The stadium is plenty loud when you are there, and not significantly quieter than any other dozen or so outdoor stadiums I've been to over the years. For some reason, it just doesn't sound that way on television, which I believe has more to do with the fact that the Patriots don't pipe in the noise that a lot of other stadiums do. When you hear crazy noise from a game on tv, next time, take a look at the crowd and see if folks are really on their feet yelling and screaming. I think you'll see that a lot of times, that's not the case. It's artificial. The Bruins and Celtics are both very, very guilty of this. Something else that people always seem to forget is that the Patriots play a significant number of their home games in cold weather. Sometimes very cold. What do people wear when it's cold? Gloves. What happens when you clap with gloves on? Nothing. Think about it for a minute. It's noticeable and has a real effect on the noise during cold weather games.
I disagree that this club will be infested with your typical corporate elite. That shit is already reserved for the club level and luxury boxes. The folks I know pulling the trigger on this are real Pats fans, season ticket holders that attend lots of games and who wouldn't be caught dead wearing red pants or drinking an appletini. The price point isn't that high to discourage the common folk. The reason I declined was because I just don't know how it would work. How many season ticket holders are they going to offer it to, and when are they going to cut if off? There's what, 50k season ticket holders? Obviously, they can't allow even 10% of them access to the club at any one time, and if they are looking to rake it in (which I seriously doubt, more on that in a second), the place will end being a mob scene. I also really like my seats (although not as much as my old ones), but if I were a season ticket holder up in the nose bleeds, you can bet your ass I'd be pulling the trigger on this. Shit, you'd basically be getting front row seats for about the same price as the actual front row seats, when you combine your ticket price with the cost of the membership.
Finally, anyone who think Kraft and Co. are doing something like this because of monetary reasons is just plain out to lunch. The Pats have been in Gilette for going on 14 years now, and they have raised the prices on our seats, I believe, one time. Once. This past season, they went to a flexible pricing model where each game has a different price based on the "importance" of the game (for example, the Denver tickets had a face value that was higher than the Buffalo tickets), with three different levels. It significantly reduced the cost of the preseason tickets that most of us end up eating anyway. The Patriots are the only team in the NFL without personal seat licenses, which is fucking awesome. If Kraft wanted to rape and pillage New England fans, he could do it very, very easily, and he doesn't. I know I'd pay much, much more than what I do now for my tickets ($1390/year per ticket) and I don't know anyone that wouldn't. Kraft is making his money elsewhere (see Patriot place, the parking lots, etc.) and I have no issue with that, but to think he's going after the "common folk" is just plain misguided. If anything, he takes care of us to the detriment of the flip flop wearing assholes, which is why you see so few of them by comparison to most other stadiums and sports, particularly down there on beloved Yawkey Way.