Don't you think 1) that BB practices situational football including each position group knowing a hurry up call or two when needed? 2) That the risk reward of overturn warrants a hurry-up? Jules catch, I mean if I were BB I'd want to hurry up too. I had no idea if it hit the ground or not watching it live. If your team isn't coached up on a hurry up play I can see your point but I have trouble believing that this team wouldn't be adequately coached to execute that level of situational football.
Certainly I have faith that Bill has called some good plays for the situation where you might want to defeat replay. But, virtually by definition, you are going to end up running a less optimal play than you would have if you weren't planning on running a quick play. Spiking the ball, for example, is certainly suboptimal. (Unless you were running out of time and intending that anyway.)
And I agree there are obvious cases. If it was 4th and 28 and you converted on a disputed play there's almost no subsequent play short of a turnover you wouldn't be happy with if it defeated replay. The Jules catch is an interesting one. Let's say that they had spiked the ball and defeated review. In hindsight that would have been bad. They would have wasted a down in a big moment in a huge game for no benefit. In real time, though, the truth of the play was sufficiently uncertain that I do think the correct situational play was to get a down run to defeat review.
But I don't think that's always the case. Like if Gronk absolutely knows that he caught the ball and could communicate that information to everyone, on a routine first down play, you'd hate to burn a down just to avoid review.
By and large, though, the notion of good situational football means that you have enough information to make an informed risk-reward decision. I think that often in these run up to the line plays you just don't have enough information except in the obvious cases. And I've literally never heard anyone talk about the delta between the play you otherwise would run and the suboptimal hurry up play you will run. Which turns on a ton of stuff, including personnel on the field, down and distance, time left in the game, etc. If the coach's instruction was "when in doubt on a close play hurry up" that would be the opposite of situational football.