We're getting to the point where there can be a real conversation on this topic and I thought it would be fun to start a thread, particularly since a Celtic is in the running this year.
I think it's a 5 man race at this point. Simmons, Tatum, and Kuzma are probably the top 3 contenders with Mitchell and Lonzo rounding out the top 5. Guys like Collins, Bell and Onunoby are not playing enough minutes to be in the conversation even though they are playing very well.
I think Simmons probably has the edge on Tatum at this point, but Tatum has a real case that may only get stronger if his offensive role continues to expand. Tatum may also benefit from being on a winning team when voting time comes around. The advanced stats are split. WS likes Tatum by a big margin, BPM thinks they are neck and neck, and RPM gives Simmons a moderate edge although that had been shrinking as the season has gone on.
I think it's a 5 man race at this point. Simmons, Tatum, and Kuzma are probably the top 3 contenders with Mitchell and Lonzo rounding out the top 5. Guys like Collins, Bell and Onunoby are not playing enough minutes to be in the conversation even though they are playing very well.
I think Simmons probably has the edge on Tatum at this point, but Tatum has a real case that may only get stronger if his offensive role continues to expand. Tatum may also benefit from being on a winning team when voting time comes around. The advanced stats are split. WS likes Tatum by a big margin, BPM thinks they are neck and neck, and RPM gives Simmons a moderate edge although that had been shrinking as the season has gone on.