Absolutely. The difference is that the In BB I Trust crowd (of which I have been a prominent member) is dwindling, and if they basically just run it back next year they risk the fan base losing interest very quickly. It will be fascinating to see but it’s not just the sports radio crowd that is questioning BB at this point.
In Bill I Trust has been a good mantra but it's not completely descriptive of how those of us in that category are actually feeling.
My fundamental thought is that rebuilding after a dynasty if difficult business in the NFL and you can ask fans of a lot of franchises about that. Add to it that there are a couple of transcendent franchises in the NFL now -- and the AFC in particular. The Patriots are a long way from being "back" in the way we want them to be "back." There is a cost to dynasties. It would be interesting to see a graph of average round by round draft pick for the past 10, 20 years, whatever.
So, the question for me is what is the best option at this point in time. Coaching turnover is hard and can send you down a difficult path for cycles. And the upside here for the next couple of years is not dramatic. Whether you fully trust in Belichick or think he has lost his fastball or even are on the fence, I hope you'd realize that the guy has got some chops. We've seen pretty significant indications of that even this year.
Last year was a playoff year. This year has been a team that has regressed and has had some really un-Belichick like moments. They tried a lot. Much of it went wrong -- both macro (Patricia), medium (Trent Browns), and micro (Jakobi yesterday). As awful as this makes us fans feel, it's making Bill feel 100 times worse. The guy understands his responsibility to the franchise and its fans and its owner. Just because he doesn't say that in press conferences doesn't mean it's not true.
I'm actually looking forward to what he tries to do about it. Because he very well may be the best coach of all time and I'd like to see what he comes up with. And it's not like the options out there are so much better. And I still have a warm feeling in my belly from the dynasty. Maybe it will set us back when we should be moving forward. Or maybe he will find a way to leave the franchise in good shape for the next guy. I'm not betting against him, for sure, and willing to take a chance. Because if it doesn't work, it's hardly like it was some guarantee that plan B would have been better. History shows it probably wouldn't have been.