Well, I could see a team thinking that Nava is more "established" than Carp given what he did in essentially a full season, but I think it would be somewhat silly. They've had roughly the same amount of MLB exposure.
I don't think either guy would bring back a "B+" prospect. JBJ is a B+ prospect. Would you give up JBJ for Nava?? Maybe you can get a guy like Barnes coming off a disappointing year, but I highly doubt they'd get a top 5 prospect out of a good farm system.
I don't think either guy would bring back a "B+" prospect. JBJ is a B+ prospect. Would you give up JBJ for Nava?? Maybe you can get a guy like Barnes coming off a disappointing year, but I highly doubt they'd get a top 5 prospect out of a good farm system.