Ting / similar cellular devices

Yaz4Ever

MemBer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 10, 2004
11,292
MA-CA-RI-AZ-NC
I recently read an article about Ting and how much you can save with their service.  Out of curiosity, I checked out their website and ran the "how much can I save" calculator.  The results were mind blowing.  So mind blowing, in fact, that I doubt I'm doing this correctly and wanted to hear from others who use Ting (or something similar) or also looked into it and found something that I'm missing that changes the savings results.
 
Below is a screenshot of what they are telling me I'll save:
 

 
I signed up for Verizon in September.  We purchased 5 iPhone 6's (4 16gb and 1 64gb).  We have 21 months remaining under contract.  I had previously been with AT&T for 9 years, so I'm not one to jump around.
 
From what I understand (and this is what I used when answering the questions needed for the calculator), I'll need to sell my Verizon iPhones as they won't work (only Sprint phones will).  They recommend a service called Glyde which quoted me $433 for each of the 16gb models and $500 for the 64gb).  They are calculating an ETF of $1650.  I think I paid for two of these phones in full, however, so that number might be a little high.  Regardless, I'd like to use it (I'll call VZ if it seems worth pursuing to get the actual numbers later) as I'd rather be pleasantly surprised that I'm saving even more if I go this route.
 
I entered the information about number of lines, data used each of the past three months, minutes used each of the past three months, messages used each of the past three months, and the bill total pre-tax for the past three months into their calculator.
 
As some of you know, I've been out of work since last February and had a major surgery ($6,000 out of pocket) this month, so money is running a bit low right now even though my wife luckily has an excellent and high-paying job.  I'm hoping to get work in the next month or so, but who knows?  Even if I was working and making good money, I'm always looking for savings.
 
How in the holy hell can I have 5 iPhones (they'd only be iPhone 5c's now) and continue to use the data, messaging, and minutes we've used on average over the past few months (likely to continue with similar numbers hereafter) and save this much money?  I know I'm missing something.  It can't possibly be this good.  Can it?
 
Only downside I see is that I'd have to convince the family to fork over their iPhone 6s and use iPhone 5c's (real first-world problem, I know, especially when I'm not contributing financially right now to the family budget).  
 
Possible major downside is the coverage.  We tried Sprint for a few weeks between AT&T and Verizon and the coverage sucked.  My wife complained constantly about it.  I've been told, however, that although Ting uses Sprint's service it also uses other services to cover weak signal areas.  Ting has this coverage map with my area on it.  If true, I have zero idea why our Sprint coverage was so bad for those few weeks we tried it.
 

 
edit:  one more thing.  We recently found out that my wife's employer has an agreement with Verizon that gives us 19% off each month.  That only starts this month, so those savings haven't been factored into what I used in the calculator - I just used what we were charged.  Not sure how much this will affect the overall savings, but I'm sure it's not enough where I'm better off staying with Verizon.
 

Marceline

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2002
6,462
Canton, MA
Ting is great. I have used them for 2 years now and have made several recommendations in the various cell phone related threads here.

My average bill over 2 years has been around $14-$15 a month, but I have very low usage - I typically stay under 100mb data and 100 minutes and I use 0 texts (I use Google voice for texting). Occasionally I go over if I'm traveling but it still ends up being around $20 or so in my case.

It sounds like you've analyzed your usage, which is great. I don't think Ting is as good for really heavy data users - I sometimes recommend those folks go to Straight Talk. But the math is probably different for a family plan anyway.

I have had no issues with Ting service and no issues with coverage. If you've checked your usage and will save on their plan then I would highly recommend it. I can also give you a referral code good for $25 for both of us if interested.
 

Boston Brawler

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 17, 2011
9,781
My brother recently ditched Verizon for Ting. He's saving about 60 dollars a month and loves it. No issues with coverage or data performance.  I plan to ditch my Verizon plan when I return from my assignment in Italy (I'm not paying them while I'm over here obviously, they placed my account/number on a hold when I moved over here). 
 

Yaz4Ever

MemBer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 10, 2004
11,292
MA-CA-RI-AZ-NC
We'
 
Joe Sixpack said:
Ting is great. I have used them for 2 years now and have made several recommendations in the various cell phone related threads here.

My average bill over 2 years has been around $14-$15 a month, but I have very low usage - I typically stay under 100mb data and 100 minutes and I use 0 texts (I use Google voice for texting). Occasionally I go over if I'm traveling but it still ends up being around $20 or so in my case.

It sounds like you've analyzed your usage, which is great. I don't think Ting is as good for really heavy data users - I sometimes recommend those folks go to Straight Talk. But the math is probably different for a family plan anyway.

I have had no issues with Ting service and no issues with coverage. If you've checked your usage and will save on their plan then I would highly recommend it. I can also give you a referral code good for $25 for both of us if interested.
We're paying for a 30gb plan with unlimited minutes and messages.
 
We average 21gb or so (so I'll lower it soon if I stay with VZ but wanted to get a few months to see actual use first) and something like 1500 messages with 700 or so minutes on the 5 lines combined.  I'll look at Straight Talk as well.  Maybe they allow us to bring our Verizon phones with us, which would simplify things a bit even if it alters the overall savings by a few hundred, which is fine if I'm honestly looking at $5,000 in savings over 2 years.  
 

IpswichSox

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
2,794
Suburbs of Washington, DC
Just curious, why do you use so much data?  
 
When I bought my two kids iPhones, I closely monitored their data usage at first and constantly reminded them that texts, tweets, emails etc. via cellular was fine but downloading, streaming or emailing a bunch hi-res photos or videos should wait until they're home or at friends' houses with wifi. We have four lines on our 10GB plan, and haven't had any real usage problems. (Verizon says its average data users go through about 1-2 GB per device per month.)
 

Yaz4Ever

MemBer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 10, 2004
11,292
MA-CA-RI-AZ-NC
IpswichSox said:
Just curious, why do you use so much data?  
 
When I bought my two kids iPhones, I closely monitored their data usage at first and constantly reminded them that texts, tweets, emails etc. via cellular was fine but downloading, streaming or emailing a bunch hi-res photos or videos should wait until they're home or at friends' houses with wifi. We have four lines on our 10GB plan, and haven't had any real usage problems. (Verizon says its average data users go through about 1-2 GB per device per month.)
My daughter has VERY weak wifi coverage at school and my wife has ZERO wifi coverage at work.  They both stream a lot of music and/or Netflix.  I use less than 2GB per month, but because I have the extra data I've been using it rather than further taxing the home wifi.  My 12yo daughter and her friends are constantly snapchatting each other while on the bus to and from school or when out doing something super exciting like have a frappacino at Starbucks (yes, I know they have wifi for their customers).  My nearly 15yo son uses less than 1GB most months, but has been using more as he likes to listen to Apple Radio/Pandora/etc on his way to and from school each day.  If I could kick my college-aged daughter off the plan (which won't fly with the wife), I'd be able to cut the family down to 15gb or maybe even 10gb (but that might be pushing it).
 

Marceline

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2002
6,462
Canton, MA
Yaz4Ever said:
We'
 
We're paying for a 30gb plan with unlimited minutes and messages.
 
We average 21gb or so (so I'll lower it soon if I stay with VZ but wanted to get a few months to see actual use first) and something like 1500 messages with 700 or so minutes on the 5 lines combined.  I'll look at Straight Talk as well.  Maybe they allow us to bring our Verizon phones with us, which would simplify things a bit even if it alters the overall savings by a few hundred, which is fine if I'm honestly looking at $5,000 in savings over 2 years.  
 
How much are you paying now with Verizon?

I just went to Ting's rate page and for 21gb, 700 minutes, 1500 texts and 5 lines you would pay $344/month. The data usage is what really brings the price up. Their rates on anything over 2gb/month are not very competitive.
 
Straight talk will give you unlimited text, unlimited minutes, "unlimited" data (they throttle your speeds above 3.5gb per line) for $45/month per line, so $225 total for your family. But they would have to curtail their usage a bit.
 
Verizon phones are not compatible with Straight Talk. They can take T-Mobile or AT&T phones. However, you can get the latest and greatest phones, so you could still use iPhone 6's, you'd just have to sell yours and get the AT&T version (full price, non-contract) instead.
 
If you could get the family's usage down to 10gb/month you'd be looking at $205/month with Ting. Maybe just tell them not to stream Netflix unless they are on a wifi network. You would save a lot that way.
 

Yaz4Ever

MemBer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 10, 2004
11,292
MA-CA-RI-AZ-NC
Joe Sixpack said:
 
How much are you paying now with Verizon?

I just went to Ting's rate page and for 21gb, 700 minutes, 1500 texts and 5 lines you would pay $344/month. The data usage is what really brings the price up.
 
Straight talk will give you unlimited text, unlimited minutes, "unlimited" data (they throttle you above 3.5gb per line) for $45/month per line, so $225 total for your family. But they would have to curtail their usage a bit.
 
If you could get the family's usage down to 10gb/month you'd be looking at $205/month with Ting.
ok, that's what I thought.  When I entered all the information, it gave me the chart above.  I knew there was no way my bill would drop that much.  If I'm looking at $344/month through Ting, I'm better off staying with Verizon.  I'm paying $372 right now, but the 19% discount kicks in next month so my bill should drop to $301.32 - $43 less than Ting and we keep our current phones.
 
My point was that there was no way my bill would drop as much as they said.  They must not be factoring in the information they asked for when calculating that chart.
 

Marceline

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2002
6,462
Canton, MA
Yaz4Ever said:
ok, that's what I thought.  When I entered all the information, it gave me the chart above.  I knew there was no way my bill would drop that much.  If I'm looking at $344/month through Ting, I'm better off staying with Verizon.  I'm paying $372 right now, but the 19% discount kicks in next month so my bill should drop to $301.32 - $43 less than Ting and we keep our current phones.
 
My point was that there was no way my bill would drop as much as they said.  They must not be factoring in the information they asked for when calculating that chart.
 
I think you might have put in 2100mb/month instead of 21000mb/month, or something along those lines.
 
I just put all your info into the Ting calculator and it comes back and says you would save $0.00 with Ting.
 

GeorgeThomas

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 4, 2007
105
Virginia
My wife and I switched to Ting from Verizon a little over a year ago. We switched from feature phones to smart phones. It monthly bill went down to an average of under $50 for the both of us. Switching plans to accommodate smart phones under Verizon would have cost us almost three times as much.

The value of Ting is the ability to pay only for what you use within a series of defined chunks. since we're on Wi-Fi most of the time it's rare that we consume more than 500mb of data.

Once you get into the multi Gb of data, the savings drops off since you're paying additional for each bit of data.
 

Yaz4Ever

MemBer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 10, 2004
11,292
MA-CA-RI-AZ-NC
Joe Sixpack said:
 
I think you might have put in 2100mb/month instead of 21000mb/month, or something along those lines.
 
I just put all your info into the Ting calculator and it comes back and says you would save $0.00 with Ting.
bingo.  Just went back to the calculator and it asks for monthly MB.  Somehow I read that as GB.  I guess because I assumed, rightly or wrongly, that most people measure their shared data in terms of GB and not MB.  My bad.  No savings to see here...at least for me.  I hope that others looked into Ting (or it's competitors), though, and found a way to save money on their cellular service because of this thread.
 

saintnick912

GINO!
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Oct 30, 2004
4,980
Somerville, MA
The secret to a cheap phone bill is not streaming music and Netflix over 4G.  It's pretty easy to not do.  I've gone over 500MB exactly zero times, with very little planning.  I had a $15 outlay for a SD card to download music to.
 
My gf loves Ting, they got her bill down to $28-36 (depending if she goes over or under one of the buckets in a given month).  It doesn't work in half of my house (nor does anything Sprint) or where my friends have a summer house in Maine.  At all.
 

Marceline

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2002
6,462
Canton, MA
saintnick912 said:
The secret to a cheap phone bill is not streaming music and Netflix over 4G.  It's pretty easy to not do.  I've gone over 500MB exactly zero times, with very little planning.  I had a $15 outlay for a SD card to download music to.
 
My gf loves Ting, they got her bill down to $28-36 (depending if she goes over or under one of the buckets in a given month).  It doesn't work in half of my house (nor does anything Sprint) or where my friends have a summer house in Maine.  At all.
 
Yeah, it doesn't really take much to adjust your usage and just learn not to do stuff that will use tons of data unless you're on wifi. I very rarely go over 100mb. Most of my monthly bills are $14 and my largest ever was $29.66.
 
In terms of your signal issue, one of these should fix that for you - my brother has one in his house and it has worked great for him:
 
https://ting.com/shop/Airave25
 

SumnerH

Malt Liquor Picker
Dope
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
32,024
Alexandria, VA
saintnick912 said:
The secret to a cheap phone bill is not streaming music and Netflix over 4G.  It's pretty easy to not do.  I've gone over 500MB exactly zero times, with very little planning.  I had a $15 outlay for a SD card to download music to.
 
 
I put my own music (and movies/shows) on the phone because I want to listen to what I like, not what Pandora/spotify are pushing.  Saving a ton of data is a nice byproduct, though.  I have unlimited data (grandfathered in on AT&T), but I've only gone over 300MB once and never over 500MB.  Even if you like using Pandora/Spotify to find new music, it seems like most people could limit that to when they're on wifi without much of a problem, and listen to their own music when they're on 4G.