I'll go with:
1. Mayweather-Hatton
2. Marquez-Vasquez II
3. Taylor-Pavlik
4. Cotto-Judah
5. Codrington-Bika
I'm looking for the perfect combination of "great fight" and "great event," as well significance to the sport itself. That's why Mayweather-Hatton takes the prize for me. Though it was, ultimately, a mismatch and an ugly fight, it WAS an exciting fight and generated tremendous attention and buzz both before, during and after the event. Trying to take a global perspective here, this from everything I've read in the British press was THE biggest fight in British boxing history. Mayweather-DLH was obviously an even more hyped (in this country) and lucrative fight, but the fight itself is generally viewed as a rather tame disappointment.
Marquez-Vasquez II was just remarkable. How rare is it these days to see two Too-10 pfp fighters not only fighting each other, but engaging in a bloody but technical war? Incredible. But outside of the hardcore fans, the Marquez-Vasquez soon-to-be-trilogy is basically unknown. Neither fighter has a big following, even in Mexico. So it lost points on my list for that.
Went with Cotto-Judah over Cotto-Mosley because, frankly, it was a much better fight. Cotto-Mosley was technically great, but featured no knockdowns, neither fighter ever even hurt and in the last few rounds, Cotto uncharacteristically hopped on his bicycle. But his fight with Judah was a war. One only wonders what might have happened if Cotto hadn't landed the low blows. Judah had him staggered in those early rounds and showed the kind of heart not normally associated with Zab Judah.
Codrington-Bika was just a hell of an exciting scrap, with both fighters on the verge of a knockout the whole way through. As the Contender Finale, on "free" basic cable, I have to assume it was one of the most-watched fights of the year. So I put it on the list.
How about
Fighter of the Year?
I gotta go all Teddy Atlas and score an even round here. Sorry!
Kelly Pavlik & Floyd Mayweather.
Pavlik emerged as boxing's next great star and he did it the way people want to see: with a series of three devastating knockouts over increasingly dangerous opponents. He culminated his year by winning the linear ("true") middleweight championship by coming back from the brink of disaster to score another show-stopping KO.
Floyd fought two of the biggest events in the recent history of boxing and won them both almost effortlessly. And he fought different styles in each, proving beyond all doubt that he is the true pound-for-pound king and, while perhaps not the greatest of all time as he claims, unquestionably the greatest fighter of his era.
Some more quick news about the upcoming year:
The Juan Diaz-Michael Katsidis fight -- a 2008 FOY candidate in advance -- is
signed. Feb. 9 is the date. Can't wait for that one.
And it's not a fight, but this should be one of the most engrossing boxing events of the year:
HBO is producing a documentary on Joe Louis and his impact on the country as a black athlete in an era of segregation, pre-Jackie Robinson. HBO always makes brilliant documentaries, so I'm really looking forward to that film.