General Offseason Thread.

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,461
Santa Monica
I'd be interested in hearing your 8 thru 15 if Harden doesn't make your list. Prior to his injury last year he was having one of his best all around seasons.
There are a ton of really good point guards
I made a rough list a few months ago. I've dug it up, feel free to pan it ;)
(I think we were discussing Fultz rank amongst PGs). You had Markelle right behind FVV ~ around 20/21

There are a lot of really good guards in the league (hence the Jaylen Brown for Forward campaign)

Here is a rough PG list. Where do you slot him?
1. Luka
2. Curry
3. SGA
4. Lilliard
5. Morant
6. Fox
7. Holiday
8. Haliburton
9. Ky-ZuZu
10. Brunson
11. Harden
12. Ball
13. Trae Young
14. Garland
15. Murray
16. White
17. Smart
18. Brogdon
19. VanVleet
20. Maxey
21. Quickly
22. Poole
23. Chris Paul
24. D'Lo Russell
25. Kevin Porter Jr
26. Dinwiddie
27. Conley
28. Caruso
29. Westbrook
30. Tyus Jones
In your list I’d slot him below that tier which ends with VanVleet so right around 20-21.
 
Last edited:

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,461
Santa Monica
I'd be interested in hearing your 8 thru 15 if Harden doesn't make your list. Prior to his injury last year he was having one of his best all around seasons.
so PAY WISE, I'd expect these 15 PGs to get paid more than Harden if they were UFA
1. Luka
2. Curry
3. SGA
4. Lillard
5. Morant
6. Fox
7. Holiday
8. Haliburton
9. Ky-ZuZu
10. Brunson
11. Jamal Murray
12. Ball
13. Trae Young
14. Garland
15. FVV
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,464
There are a ton of really good point guards
I made a rough list a few months ago. I've dug it up, feel free to pan it ;)
(I think we were discussing Fultz rank amongst PGs). You had Markelle right behind FVV ~ around 20/21
You have Harden at 11 there which is in the same ballpark as me due to, as you said, there being a shit ton of real good PG's right now. Quick glance I'd consider every name in that top 15 a "star."
 

chilidawg

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 22, 2015
6,055
Cultural hub of the universe
There are a ton of really good point guards
I made a rough list a few months ago. I've dug it up, feel free to pan it ;)
(I think we were discussing Fultz rank amongst PGs). You had Markelle right behind FVV ~ around 20/21
How would you rank them if your criteria was guys I want on my team if I'm trying to win a championship?

Curry

SGA
Murray
Holiday

Haliburton
White
Smart
Brunson
Fox
FVV
Brogdon

Lillard
Morant
Trae
Harden
KI
Ball
Garland
Paul
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,461
Santa Monica
You have Harden at 11 there which is in the same ballpark as me due to, as you said, there being a shit ton of real good PG's right now. Quick glance I'd consider every name in that top 15 a "star."
That's fair, did you think Houston would have been better off giving FVV's contract to James instead of Fred?
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,461
Santa Monica
How would you rank them if your criteria was guys I want on my team if I'm trying to win a championship?

Curry

SGA
Murray
Holiday

Haliburton
White
Smart
Brunson
Fox
FVV
Brogdon

Lillard
Morant
Trae
Harden
KI
Ball
Garland
Paul
Derrick White #1, then the rest...JK.

Yea your list seems about right, although Smart really lost a step defensively last year & I'd move him down quite a bit. BUT that may have been due to injury.

and Luka/Lillard would be pretty high, right after Curry
 

JakeRae

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 21, 2005
8,197
New York, NY
How would you rank them if your criteria was guys I want on my team if I'm trying to win a championship?

Curry

SGA
Murray
Holiday

Haliburton
White
Smart
Brunson
Fox
FVV
Brogdon

Lillard
Morant
Trae
Harden
KI
Ball
Garland
Paul
This list, especially at the top, is way too driven by teammate quality. Murray is only in that second tier if Jokic is stapled to him. Same for Jrue and Giannis. I love Smart but he and White are way too high because they play with Tatum. Brogdon even more so. I don’t understand Brunson and FVV at all.

The actual trying to win list is probably more like (tiers aren’t ordered here):

Curry

Doncic
SGA
Lillard

Harden
Morant
Fox
Halliburton
Jrue

Ball
Trae
Garland
Murray
White
Smart
Brunson
Paul











Kyrie
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,464
That's fair, did you think Houston would have been better off giving FVV's contract to James instead of Fred?
Meh, they both move the needle similarly with that team in what they bring. FVV is probably a better fit with a younger group even though I'm not a very big fan of his game.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,993
I say this in the nicest way......

you are insane if Marcus Smart is even on your list at all of PGs for a title team. He was proably the 3rd best PG on a team that was a title favorite last year, and his inability to run offense like a point guard was a major issue (among others) that lead to a disappointing post-season. He's at his best at this point of his career as either a defense 1st SG (the small PGs give him problems on D now) or a 6th man.
 

radsoxfan

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 9, 2009
13,765
I say this in the nicest way......

you are insane if Marcus Smart is even on your list at all of PGs for a title team. He was proably the 3rd best PG on a team that was a title favorite last year, and his inability to run offense like a point guard was a major issue (among others) that lead to a disappointing post-season. He's at his best at this point of his career as either a defense 1st SG (the small PGs give him problems on D now) or a 6th man.
That wasn’t too nice…. (I don’t disagree)
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,993
That wasn’t too nice…. (I don’t disagree)
lol I meant nicest way as in "this isn't ripping Marcus, he's a good player, he just isn't a PG for a serious team" there is a reason the team that spent assets to get him wants him to be backup PG and possibly start at the 2, that's the best role for him.
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,464
I say this in the nicest way......

you are insane if Marcus Smart is even on your list at all of PGs for a title team. He was proably the 3rd best PG on a team that was a title favorite last year, and his inability to run offense like a point guard was a major issue (among others) that lead to a disappointing post-season. He's at his best at this point of his career as either a defense 1st SG (the small PGs give him problems on D now) or a 6th man.
I had been saying this about Smart-the-PG since before everyone wanted to force him into that role. He's gotten to where he's fine in the regular season but gets exposed in the playoffs....much like Jaylen's handle. He defends wings/bigs much better than he does quicks on the perimeter.
 

luckiestman

Son of the Harpy
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
32,912

chilidawg

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 22, 2015
6,055
Cultural hub of the universe
Derrick White #1, then the rest...JK.

Yea your list seems about right, although Smart really lost a step defensively last year & I'd move him down quite a bit. BUT that may have been due to injury.

and Luka/Lillard would be pretty high, right after Curry
Obviously teammates and context matter, but I have a preference for guys who play D and for those who have shown they can win at the highest level. Luka and Lillard lost some points for me on both of those.
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,461
Santa Monica
What other MVP potential players just say “no, I’m happy to be a fringe all star”. This guy worked so hard to develop his offensive game and has just thrown in the towel at maximizing his potential. I’ve seen it with fighters but not NBA guys that I remember.
If Morey doesn't deal Harden it's going to be a season of sham injuries, fake maladies, & late nights at Spearmint Rhino (some things never change)
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,993
Weird thing about Harden.... last year was his best non-MVP year to me. He found a nice balance between setting up others and himself, his defense was.... pretty good? He was probably the 76ers best player in the BOS series despite the inconsistency. But, I think he didn't really like it, and he felt like he didn't get the public appreciation he expected for deferring to Embiid. I also kind of think he felt like "everyone blamed me in the playoffs even though Joel was worse, why should I stick around to get blamed if I'm not even the #1"
 

DeJesus Built My Hotrod

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 24, 2002
48,807
Harden was super efficient last season - like peak efficiency. If people are relying on traditional or counting stats to analyze performance they can miss a lot of good stuff.
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,461
Santa Monica
Everyone around here thinks James Harden was a good player last season. Although he was much better when he was super high usage & playing practically every game for 5-years.

The problem now for James is NBA GMs don't want to pay him as a top PG anymore. I'm guessing they aren't relying on counting stats but who knows they are not infallible.
 

lovegtm

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2013
12,357
Everyone around here thinks James Harden was a good player last season. Although he was much better when he was super high usage & playing practically every game for 5-years.

The problem now for James is NBA GMs don't want to pay him as a top PG anymore. I'm guessing they aren't relying on counting stats but who knows they are not infallible.
The issue is that he's still elite when healthy, but everyone saw how limited he was in the postseason when he didn't have a million days off to rest his Achilles.

I think GMs just worry that there are too many things that can go wrong for him in too many ways, and he can't afford to lose much of a step.
 

Jimbodandy

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 31, 2006
11,598
around the way
I love the "If you want to win" lists that moved up Dame and Luka at the top, two guys who don't ever win...who helmed the 11 and 13 seeds this past season.
 
Last edited:

TripleOT

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 4, 2007
7,796
I love the "If you to win" lists that moved up Dame and Luka at the top, two guys who don't ever win...who helmed the 11 and 13 seeds this past season.
Murray is too low on this “want to win” list. When available, he shines in the biggest moments.
 

NomarsFool

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2001
8,289
Orlando traded for a pick swap with Phoenix?!? Or did Phoenix have some other team’s pick to swap with them? Because on surface, I don’t get it.
 

DeJesus Built My Hotrod

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 24, 2002
48,807
Orlando traded for a pick swap with Phoenix?!? Or did Phoenix have some other team’s pick to swap with them? Because on surface, I don’t get it.
I wouldn't overthink this transaction. Phoenix is veteran-heavy contender that needs as much flexibility as possible - second round picks seem to be the most liquid trading vehicle under the new CBA so the way to read this whole trade is just the teams consolidating assets. That pick swap is likely more valuable to Orlando (who hopefully is in ascendancy in 2026) than it is to the Suns. In the end, Phoenix gets Bol and three seconds in exchange for Payne, a second, a pick swap and cash.
 

Swedgin

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 27, 2013
702
Orlando traded for a pick swap with Phoenix?!? Or did Phoenix have some other team’s pick to swap with them? Because on surface, I don’t get it.
Phoenix already traded a swap to Washington in the Beal trade. So Orlando is really betting on being better than both Washington and the Suns during the 2025-2026 season.

At the start of the 2025-2026 season Durant will be 38 and Beal with be 33, so that's not an insane bet, if not necessarily one I would take.

None of the seconds involved in the deal are likely to be "good" seconds. According to WOJ they are 2024 Denver, 2026 least desirable of Milwaukee, Orlando and Detroit and 2028 Boston (protected up to 46).

Strikes me as Suns coming up with a creative way to at least get something back in its asset portfolio to include in feature deals, since the Beal traded left them with nothing (except secondary swaps) and Orlando gets a lottery ticket.
 

wade boggs chicken dinner

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 26, 2005
30,880
For those who haven't heard it, Lowe Post Podcast had Larry Nance Jr. on. Really entertaining. Nance Jr. says he wants to be in a NBA front office after he plays and it sounds like he could do it. Some good observations and great stories.

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/begley-nance-and-wasch/id986595124?i=1000621069537, around the 35:15 mark).

After Nance Jr., the guest is a member of the NBA league office who talks not only about the new tournament but also talks about some rules the NBA has considered in the past.
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,464
I want that dude to be on the Celtics. Easy one to root for. Seems like a solid dude
So are many of those first generation offspring of NBA players. Something to be said for growing up around the game while having an NBA father as your mentor.
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,461
Santa Monica
Steph, who was down most of the day, and down 3 on 18 (modified Stableford scoring), sinks eagle putt to win the whole freaking tournament. First active athlete to win the tourney since 2000.

View: https://twitter.com/NBCSWarriors/status/1680699458122838016
Steph goes even beyond that. A fan screamed in the middle of Mardy Fish's backswing on the 18th tee & Fish flubbed it. Curry felt awful & asked Mardy if he wanted to re-load (take another/do-over). Fish declined. That takes so much focus under the circumstances. Steph goes ahead & pipes his drive down the middle, sticks a long iron 10' away from the pin, & early celebrates a putt before it falls in for Eagle on 18. I can't ever remember a PGA Tour event where a player had an eagle on 18 to win by 1.

Screw Bron & MJ, Steph is the GOAT...
 

Phil Plantier

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 7, 2002
3,421
Phoenix already traded a swap to Washington in the Beal trade. So Orlando is really betting on being better than both Washington and the Suns during the 2025-2026 season.

[...]

Strikes me as Suns coming up with a creative way to at least get something back in its asset portfolio to include in feature deals, since the Beal traded left them with nothing (except secondary swaps) and Orlando gets a lottery ticket.
Something that's been bothering me: the new CBA says (I think) that teams that go over the second apron will pick last in the first round. Is Phoenix trading all of these swaps knowing that they are worthless?
 

ElUno20

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
6,158
In 2023, an nba mvp knows exactly what saying that does and the wildfire it starts. Especially, Embiid who is a top tier grade A troll.
 

ugmo33

Member
SoSH Member
May 6, 2016
166
Something that's been bothering me: the new CBA says (I think) that teams that go over the second apron will pick last in the first round. Is Phoenix trading all of these swaps knowing that they are worthless?
There seems to be a trend in thinking that second-round picks are going to be more valuable to capped-out teams in the world of the new CBA. I guess just because they are cheaper and more flexible contracts
 

DavidTai

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 18, 2003
1,257
Herndon, VA
There seems to be a trend in thinking that second-round picks are going to be more valuable to capped-out teams in the world of the new CBA. I guess just because they are cheaper and more flexible contracts
The second round picks exemption don't count towards the MLE, which allows teams to sign their second rounder picks longer than they used to. Previously, they could only sign them to two years contract, and to sign them longer meant using part of the MLE. A 2nd rounder can be signed to 4 years 7 million right now. (A huge bargain if you happen to hit on a 2nd round pick... Jordan Walsh is signed to one of those 2nd round exemptions contracts.)

This also means teams now have full use of the MLE for veterans, and not have to reserve some of that for any 2nd rounder they want to sign for longer than two years.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,993
There seems to be a trend in thinking that second-round picks are going to be more valuable to capped-out teams in the world of the new CBA. I guess just because they are cheaper and more flexible contracts
They're a little more valuable, also for PHX it's just about having something, anything of value to add to their team. They're really short on ways to add talent, and it's just going to get worse.
 

wade boggs chicken dinner

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 26, 2005
30,880
Something that's been bothering me: the new CBA says (I think) that teams that go over the second apron will pick last in the first round. Is Phoenix trading all of these swaps knowing that they are worthless?
None of the picks currently being traded are implicated. The new rules state that if a team is above the 2nd apron as of the end of the 2024-25 league year, then the 1st round pick 7 years out (the "Frozen Pick") can't be traded. Because of league rules, these picks cannot currently be traded and as I understand it, there's no possibility of a potential frozen pick being traded.

So if the team remains above the 2nd apron for two additional years out of the next four (3 years out of 5 in aggregate), then the Frozen Pick drops to the end of the 1st round.

https://theathletic.com/4607105/2023/06/28/nba-cba-new-rules/
 

cheech13

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 5, 2006
1,608
Who is actually playing PG for the Suns after trading Paul and Payne? Are they just assuming that one of their big 3 will always have the ball so it doesn’t particularly matter? That seems crazy.
 

Jimbodandy

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 31, 2006
11,598
around the way
Who is actually playing PG for the Suns after trading Paul and Payne? Are they just assuming that one of their big 3 will always have the ball so it doesn’t particularly matter? That seems crazy.
Two good ball-handling combo guards and a great ball-handling forward is a nice problem to have. They'll have some usage kinks to work out, but it shouldn't matter much who initiates more. All three can pass and handle the ball just fine.
 

Havlicheck

New Member
Jan 31, 2014
44
Who is actually playing PG for the Suns after trading Paul and Payne? Are they just assuming that one of their big 3 will always have the ball so it doesn’t particularly matter? That seems crazy.
Booker played at least 12-20 minutes at point in a number of games over the last two years during Paul’s absences. I expect him to assume a larger role in this regard. He turns the ball over a fair amount and has a hard time guarding quicker point guards on defense. If he doesn’t work out, he’ll go back to the 3 and they’ll sign Kemba or Kyrie (s/). Ishbia has money to burn and he’s burning it, while his buddy Zeke Thomas whispers sweet nothings in his ear…