OK, now that NY has clinched, let me take a quick crack at this. Keep in mind that this roster is just for the wild card game, and if they advance to the ALDS, they can change it accordingly:
Definitely on (19):
McCann
Bird
Ackley/Refsnyder
Gregorius
Headley
Gardner
Ellsbury
Beltran
A-Rod
Refsnyder/Ackley
Murphy
Young
Noel
Tanaka
Mitchell
Warren
Wilson
Betances
Miller
That leaves six spots, probably mostly pitchers, but so few good options. I wouldn't be surprised to see any of these guys make it or be left off:
Severino (3 days rest after starting tomorrow, but still)
Pazos
Shreve
Bailey
Rumbelow
Cotham
Sabathia
Nova (depending how he is used this weekend)
Pineda (same)
Other position players, maybe Heathcott? Eovaldi would be a great relief option, but I don't think there's almost any chance he'd be ready by Tuesday.
Definitely on (19):
McCann
Bird
Ackley/Refsnyder
Gregorius
Headley
Gardner
Ellsbury
Beltran
A-Rod
Refsnyder/Ackley
Murphy
Young
Noel
Tanaka
Mitchell
Warren
Wilson
Betances
Miller
That leaves six spots, probably mostly pitchers, but so few good options. I wouldn't be surprised to see any of these guys make it or be left off:
Severino (3 days rest after starting tomorrow, but still)
Pazos
Shreve
Bailey
Rumbelow
Cotham
Sabathia
Nova (depending how he is used this weekend)
Pineda (same)
Other position players, maybe Heathcott? Eovaldi would be a great relief option, but I don't think there's almost any chance he'd be ready by Tuesday.