Perhaps, but that seems like a poor use of resources long-term.
I'm #teamvazquez because, if his defensive gifts really are what they appear to be, that's a weapon you can't replicate, no matter who else is on your roster. It's not like, say, the outfield, where JBJ in center and Victorino in right means we can put a statue in left, and it's not like the lineup, where you can get away with a liability in the #9 hole if the hitters around him can make up for it.
Besides, I think we're only beginning to understand how important pitch-framing skills are, and I have to think his talent there is only going to become more valuable as we do. Basically, in my mind, he'd have to be a true offensive liability to not be my Catcher of the Future.
I also really like Swihart, who looks like he could offer above-average offense and average-to-above-average defense. But he's worth more to a team that doesn't have its own Junior Molina, and so I'd rather take advantage of that.
That all assumes, of course, that Vazquez ISN'T a true offensive liability, and I'm really glad we ditched AJP so we could start to find out in advance of whatever Stanton/Heyward/BinkyTK talks we end up having this winter.