Old convo,but I am suprised by how good Lynn actually looks in terms of career stats. 50 bWAR career--better than Jim Rice, 1 less than Papi. I know, not apples to oranges given the DH thing, but still, I think of him as having completely fallen off the map in his early 30s, but he managed to play until 38 and mostly be decent. Of course, he got almost a quarter of his value in a single season... I mean, if Gedman doesn't count because in his prime he was actually good, Lynn shouldn't either. But I think both do count.
My list is soooo long. Jeremy Giambi, Paxton Crawford, Awesome Fossum, Bellhorn, Manny Delcarmen, Sam Horn, BH Kim (I still want to argue that "he was actually good"), Dice-K, Izzy A., Hee Seop Choi, Daubach, Middlebrooks... on and on. In my defense, I knew Benzinger sucked, but I loved him anyway!