Cora, Cora, Cora!

soxin6

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
7,034
Huntington Beach, CA
Free agency is also not the only method to which an organization can acquire players.
To this point, we have not seen a willingness from Chaim to give up a package of prospects for a starting pitcher. The rumors of the offer for Snell were something we haven’t seen before from Bloom. The hardest part of running baseball ops is getting rid of the minor leaguers that you don’t see a future in and turn them into major league talent. Let’s hope we see a Beckett level move this summer.
 

Sandy Leon Trotsky

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 11, 2007
6,499
To this point, we have not seen a willingness from Chaim to give up a package of prospects for a starting pitcher. The rumors of the offer for Snell were something we haven’t seen before from Bloom. The hardest part of running baseball ops is getting rid of the minor leaguers that you don’t see a future in and turn them into major league talent. Let’s hope we see a Beckett level move this summer.
I haven’t seen anything at all on the Snell rumors until your post. What was the supposed rumored package???
 

Merkle's Boner

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 24, 2011
3,832
SoSH is sometimes very weird in what they focus on. A day after Cora benches a starter, the Sox lose the game on an absolutely horrendous base running/third base coaching error, sounds furious in the post-game press conference, and says it’s one of the darkest days of his tenure as a Sox manager, the focus in the Manager thread is about his bullpen usage. There are some bigger issues to discuss with this team, no? Are we seeing the final days of Alex Cora?
 

YTF

Member
SoSH Member
I know that and that's why I deleted that part of your post. I agree with you whole heartedly that something needs to be done and I think that Cora is going about it the right way behind closed doors. Some of the players that you "did" mention are gone btw and Duran has picked it up this year. Bloom sent the message by moving them off the team (75%anyways)
Those particular players being off the team was not a result of what we're discussing here. They weren't very good and there was no longer a place for them here.
 

soxin6

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
7,034
Huntington Beach, CA
I haven’t seen anything at all on the Snell rumors until your post. What was the supposed rumored package???
It was a rumor that was out there, but who knows if it was real because now I can’t find it. There were so many rumors about what didn’t happen with the Sox that it is hard to know what was real and what was fiction.
 

soxin6

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
7,034
Huntington Beach, CA
SoSH is sometimes very weird in what they focus on. A day after Cora benches a starter, the Sox lose the game on an absolutely horrendous base running/third base coaching error, sounds furious in the post-game press conference, and says it’s one of the darkest days of his tenure as a Sox manager, the focus in the Manager thread is about his bullpen usage. There are some bigger issues to discuss with this team, no? Are we seeing the final days of Alex Cora?
I don’t think Cora will be back next year, but that is based on nothing. When Cora took over in 2018, he had a stacked team than dominated the league and won the WS. Since his return in 2021, it has been a rollercoaster ride where management has not invested in the team at the deadline two straight years. Cora could get another job with a franchise that is in a different phase of their development.
 

grimshaw

Member
SoSH Member
May 16, 2007
4,231
Portland
Okay, expand the pool to any of the free agent starters who signed multi-year contracts. Here's the list from shortest/cheapest to longest:

Seth Lugo (2/15)
Jordan Lyles (2/17)
Drew Smyly (2/19)
Andrew Heaney (2/25)
Sean Manaea (2/25)
Ross Stripling (2/25)
Jose Quintana (2/26)
Nathan Eovaldi (2/34)
Justin Verlander (2/86.6)
Tyler Anderson (3/39)
Zach Eflin (3/40)
Chris Bassitt (3/63)
Michael Wacha (4/26)
Jameson Taillon (4/68)
Taijuan Walker (4/72)
Kodai Senga (5/75)
Jacob deGrom (5/185)
Carlos Rodon (6/162)

Who ya want? Two of those guys are currently under the age of 30. One is Eflin (28) to whom the Sox reportedly made a strong competitive offer, but he chose Tampa for similar money. The other is Senga (29).
The Sox were heavily in on Senga as well. Can't find the quote but I believe he also didn't want to pitch here.

Regardless, Kluber was the worst pitcher in baseball when on the roster. At least they went small.
 
Last edited:

Red(s)HawksFan

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 23, 2009
20,963
Maine
It was a rumor that was out there, but who knows if it was real because now I can’t find it. There were so many rumors about what didn’t happen with the Sox that it is hard to know what was real and what was fiction.
If it was a rumor at all, I'd expect it would have surfaced in one of the deadline threads here. The only mentions of Snell I could find in a quick search was a poster naming Snell in a wishlist kind of way, and then there was discussion spun off that post. I don't believe Snell was ever a consideration.
 

moondog80

heart is two sizes two small
SoSH Member
Sep 20, 2005
8,281
To this point, we have not seen a willingness from Chaim to give up a package of prospects for a starting pitcher. The rumors of the offer for Snell were something we haven’t seen before from Bloom. The hardest part of running baseball ops is getting rid of the minor leaguers that you don’t see a future in and turn them into major league talent. Let’s hope we see a Beckett level move this summer.
To this point, the Sox haven't been a position where it made sense to do so. The prospects were not there, and the teams' playoff chances weren't high enough. The tide is turning however, and I do think we will see a move for a starter this offseason (though my money is on it being Yoshi Yamamoto, a free agent).

And if you put the line for # of top Sox 20 prospects getting traded this offseason (for a pitcher or otherwise) at 1.5, I'll take the over.
 

Yelling At Clouds

Post-darwinian
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
3,449
I haven’t seen anything at all on the Snell rumors until your post. What was the supposed rumored package???
It was a rumor that was out there, but who knows if it was real because now I can’t find it. There were so many rumors about what didn’t happen with the Sox that it is hard to know what was real and what was fiction.
If it was a rumor at all, I'd expect it would have surfaced in one of the deadline threads here. The only mentions of Snell I could find in a quick search was a poster naming Snell in a wishlist kind of way, and then there was discussion spun off that post. I don't believe Snell was ever a consideration.
Possibly referring to this? Looked sketchy to the point of bogus to me, but I guess you never know.
 

LogansDad

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 15, 2006
29,830
Alamogordo
Yes timing is everything. That’s why when four starters or potential starters are on the IL (Houck, Sale, Kluber and Whitlock) you SELL at the deadline not try to patch together a bullpen rotation to support an undisciplined team that makes way to many mental mistakes in a very tough division.
In the home games prior to this weekend's disaster, the team has been drawing 36K+ in attendance, and they were 1.5 games out of the wild card at the trade deadline, and had the best record in the league in July. How in the world was selling the right option?

Aside from the message it would have sent to the fans and organization, the players who might have been available to move (Paxton, Duvall, maybe Turner or the relievers, and possibly Verdugo) weren't going to bring back anything special anyway (and before you say "Look what the Mets got for Verlander and Scherzer, well.... they are Verlander and Scherzer, NOT James Paxton, and anyone who thinks Paxton was going to bring back anything close to what they did is drinking some serious milkshakes).
 

JCizzle

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 11, 2006
20,718
In the home games prior to this weekend's disaster, the team has been drawing 36K+ in attendance, and they were 1.5 games out of the wild card at the trade deadline, and had the best record in the league in July. How in the world was selling the right option?

Aside from the message it would have sent to the fans and organization, the players who might have been available to move (Paxton, Duvall, maybe Turner or the relievers, and possibly Verdugo) weren't going to bring back anything special anyway (and before you say "Look what the Mets got for Verlander and Scherzer, well.... they are Verlander and Scherzer, NOT James Paxton, and anyone who thinks Paxton was going to bring back anything close to what they did is drinking some serious milkshakes).
Would selling have sent a worse message to the organization than what we've seen on the field since the deadline? Would they be losing by 20 to the Jays instead?
 

RedOctober3829

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
55,525
deep inside Guido territory
Would selling have sent a worse message to the organization than what we've seen on the field since the deadline? Would they be losing by 20 to the Jays instead?
If he sold, at least we would know he has some conviction behind the supposed plan he has. If he truly is playing for 2024 or 2025, then selling off pieces at the deadline would make some sense. The indecision he has had at the deadline 2 years in a row is mind-blowing to me. Even in 2021 when he got Schwarber, he traded for an injured player who couldn't play for about 2 weeks then shoehorned him into a position he never played before.
 

jbupstate

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2022
614
New York, USA
If he sold, at least we would know he has some conviction behind the supposed plan he has. If he truly is playing for 2024 or 2025, then selling off pieces at the deadline would make some sense. The indecision he has had at the deadline 2 years in a row is mind-blowing to me. Even in 2021 when he got Schwarber, he traded for an injured player who couldn't play for about 2 weeks then shoehorned him into a position he never played before.
What indecision? They feel they have players coming back that could get them in to the playoffs this year. They did not feel giving up value this year would improve the odds this year without hindering they chances going forward.

A great offer for Paxton wasn’t enough to give up the remainder of of Paxton’s season and the QO pick. Does anybody really think Turner was bringing back a SP with control who slots above the guys coming back?
 

Reggie's Racquet

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2009
7,258
Florida/Montana
If he sold, at least we would know he has some conviction behind the supposed plan he has. If he truly is playing for 2024 or 2025, then selling off pieces at the deadline would make some sense. The indecision he has had at the deadline 2 years in a row is mind-blowing to me. Even in 2021 when he got Schwarber, he traded for an injured player who couldn't play for about 2 weeks then shoehorned him into a position he never played before.
Totally agree.
 

Patriot_Reign

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 21, 2011
1,159
If he sold, at least we would know he has some conviction behind the supposed plan he has. If he truly is playing for 2024 or 2025, then selling off pieces at the deadline would make some sense. The indecision he has had at the deadline 2 years in a row is mind-blowing to me. Even in 2021 when he got Schwarber, he traded for an injured player who couldn't play for about 2 weeks then shoehorned him into a position he never played before.
Agree.
Bloom waffles.
Don't want to hear him try to sell that nonsense that Sale and Story returning are all the moves they needed to make.
 

Auger34

used to be tbb
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
9,726
Wrong about Kluber. Read above.
Wrong about Kluber. See below (ERA+ of 85)

To be clear, neither of you are right or wrong but to act like your series of cherry picked stats (walks and QS) and moved goalposts (apparently the Sox can only sign pitchers to one year deals in your calculus ?) somehow ends the argument of whether signing an injury prone, old pitcher was prudent use of resources is insane and shows a lot of hubris
 

RedOctober3829

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
55,525
deep inside Guido territory
What indecision? They feel they have players coming back that could get them in to the playoffs this year. They did not feel giving up value this year would improve the odds this year without hindering they chances going forward.

A great offer for Paxton wasn’t enough to give up the remainder of of Paxton’s season and the QO pick. Does anybody really think Turner was bringing back a SP with control who slots above the guys coming back?
The indecision in picking a lane. If he thought this team was worth investing in, then go out and get players that could help them make the playoffs. If he didn’t believe they could make playoffs, sell off pieces that could get some decent prospects back in return.

What future chances were being hindered by buying at this deadline? You either could have acquired a SP with term left and look at it as a 2024 move or a cheaper rental such as Rich Hill to help in the short term.

Is Bloom going to continually horde his prospects or is he going to eventually figure out which ones to help the team on the field and which ones to deal for established talent? You can fault DD for a lot of things w/the farm, but one thing you can’t is he identified ones to trade. He did a great job in the Sale, Kimbrel, and Eovaldi deals.
 

rodderick

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 24, 2009
12,950
Belo Horizonte - Brazil
The indecision in picking a lane. If he thought this team was worth investing in, then go out and get players that could help them make the playoffs. If he didn’t believe they could make playoffs, sell off pieces that could get some decent prospects back in return.

What future chances were being hindered by buying at this deadline? You either could have acquired a SP with term left and look at it as a 2024 move or a cheaper rental such as Rich Hill to help in the short term.

Is Bloom going to continually horde his prospects or is he going to eventually figure out which ones to help the team on the field and which ones to deal for established talent? You can fault DD for a lot of things w/the farm, but one thing you can’t is he identified ones to trade. He did a great job in the Sale, Kimbrel, and Eovaldi deals.
People talk of Bloom as if building a good farm system means just hoarding as many guys as you can. Anyone can do that in a big market, especially if the major league team struggles and you pick high in the draft. Really, if the sole focus is system building you can accomplish that with relative ease, I still don't understand why people talk about it as this massive achievement. Now putting together a consistent pipeline of talent that continuously feeds the big league club while identifying which guys are overvalued and can be better employed in trades for veteran talent, now that's hard as hell. And since Bloom hasn't done that, I don't see why he should get kudos for farm system rankings. Those only matter as much as they materialize into wins for the Boston Red Sox. I'll agree it's too soon to judge him on that, so it's ridiculous to say he's failed at that part of his job but he sure as hell hasn't succeeded either, and many people seem to believe he has.
 

Sandy Leon Trotsky

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 11, 2007
6,499
It’s also possible that Bloom sees the prospects he thinks can be traded aren’t t as valuable as they will be in the offseason…. And the ones he wants to hold onto aren’t ready to contribute?
It’s a balancing act but maybe Yorke wasnt the best trade bait? (Just using him as an example)
 

JimD

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 29, 2001
8,696
Bloom certainly could have done a better job cashing in a few prospect chips for reinforcements, but Cora doing (a lot) better job in cutting down on the baserunning blunders and improving the team's fielding performance shouldn't be overlooked in the rush to run Chaim out of town. It's the equivalent of walking and chewing gum at the same time.
 

Patriot_Reign

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 21, 2011
1,159
, but Cora doing (a lot) better job in cutting down on the baserunning blunders and improving the team's fielding performance shouldn't be overlooked in the rush to run Chaim out of town. It's the equivalent of walking and chewing gum at the same time.
The idea that Cora and his staff have to spend time teaching basic fundamentals to supposed major league level players is pretty offensive.
 

YTF

Member
SoSH Member
It was a rumor that was out there, but who knows if it was real because now I can’t find it. There were so many rumors about what didn’t happen with the Sox that it is hard to know what was real and what was fiction.
Yeah, I remember seeing something about Snell. Pretty much the generic and gratuitous "Red Sox are reportedly in talks/in on/asking about Blake Snell.".
 

JCizzle

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 11, 2006
20,718
The idea that Cora and his staff have to spend time teaching basic fundamentals to supposed major league level players is pretty offensive.
Bring back Bobby V!! It worked out great the last time we had a manger treat the team like little leaguers.
 

Petagine in a Bottle

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 13, 2021
12,350
Bring back Bobby V!! It worked out great the last time we had a manger treat the team like little leaguers.
Amazingly, that team was only 2 games off this teams pace through 110 games (they were 55-55).

Playoffs or not, would be nice to see this team finish the season strong. Going to be really difficult to feel good about next year if this year ends the way last year did.

I do not think Cora survives a sub .500 season.
 

canderson

Mr. Brightside
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
39,659
Harrisburg, Pa.
This season is spinning off the rails and this team struggles with basic baseball fundamentals (a trend getting worse under Cora). At this point I’d be surprised if Cora comes back next year. The failed and poorly constructed roster isn’t his fault - but the poor and uninterested play is.
 
Last edited:

Jinhocho

Moderator
Moderator
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2001
10,290
Durham, NC
I was honestly surprised they brought him back. I will be glad to see him go. I am not sure he has lost the team, but he certainly does not seem to have them all pulling in tandem.
 

moondog80

heart is two sizes two small
SoSH Member
Sep 20, 2005
8,281
How happy would people be if Bloom "picked a lane" by trading Cedanne Rafaella and Blaze Jordan for Blake Snell and they went 2-6 instead of 1-7 in their last 8 games?
 

Fishercat

Svelte and sexy!
SoSH Member
May 18, 2007
8,358
Manchester, N.H.
The indecision in picking a lane. If he thought this team was worth investing in, then go out and get players that could help them make the playoffs. If he didn’t believe they could make playoffs, sell off pieces that could get some decent prospects back in return.

What future chances were being hindered by buying at this deadline? You either could have acquired a SP with term left and look at it as a 2024 move or a cheaper rental such as Rich Hill to help in the short term.

Is Bloom going to continually horde his prospects or is he going to eventually figure out which ones to help the team on the field and which ones to deal for established talent? You can fault DD for a lot of things w/the farm, but one thing you can’t is he identified ones to trade. He did a great job in the Sale, Kimbrel, and Eovaldi deals.
I mean like 2/3 of this forum said "hold" maybe only selling off excess pieces which is what Bloom did. Like...I can get the frustration but most of us didn't want to pick a lane, so I don't know if we can really get on the Sox for doing the same
 

Yelling At Clouds

Post-darwinian
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
3,449
I was under the impression that the Red Sox had traded for a starting 2B (they gave up a prospect to do so!), jettisoning two of their worst regulars in the process, so I'm not sure what "inactivity" people are talking about.
 

Merkle's Boner

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 24, 2011
3,832
The more frustrating thing to me is the non-use of Story this weekend, and to a lesser extent Sale. I don’t know who is to blame, if anyone is, but it’s pretty weak sauce for Story to decide unilaterally to use all of his allotted rehab time in Worcester. I would love to know what role Bloom has in that decision. I am also fascinated in seeing what comes of Verdugo over the next month. I assume his days here are numbered.
 

Bob Montgomerys Helmet Hat

has big, douchey shoulders
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
The more frustrating thing to me is the non-use of Story this weekend, and to a lesser extent Sale. I don’t know who is to blame, if anyone is, but it’s pretty weak sauce for Story to decide unilaterally to use all of his allotted rehab time in Worcester. I would love to know what role Bloom has in that decision. I am also fascinated in seeing what comes of Verdugo over the next month. I assume his days here are numbered.
The next month won't be fascinating for Verdugo's fate. But the off-season very well may be.
 

moondog80

heart is two sizes two small
SoSH Member
Sep 20, 2005
8,281
The more frustrating thing to me is the non-use of Story this weekend, and to a lesser extent Sale. I don’t know who is to blame, if anyone is, but it’s pretty weak sauce for Story to decide unilaterally to use all of his allotted rehab time in Worcester. I would love to know what role Bloom has in that decision. I am also fascinated in seeing what comes of Verdugo over the next month. I assume his days here are numbered.
I get questioning Story (though at the moment I'm cautiously giving him the benefit of the doubt). But pitchers need time.
 

Merkle's Boner

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 24, 2011
3,832
I get questioning Story (though at the moment I'm cautiously giving him the benefit of the doubt). But pitchers need time.
He hit another HR today. Sale also looked great, but I agree that pitchers need more time. I’m just sick of these bullpen games.
 

YTF

Member
SoSH Member
I'm more concerned with their failure to do so.
Agreed.
The idea that Cora and his staff have to spend time teaching basic fundamentals to supposed major league level players is pretty offensive.
Teams have hitting coaches, pitching coaches, base running coaches and positional coaches at THE MAJOR LEAGUE LEVEL. It's the coach's job to help players identify and fix flaws in all aspects of their game. There is no reason to expect that a major league staff couldn't or shouldn't be consistently reinforcing defensive positioning/coverage, cut off plays, run down play, pick off plays, smart base running, etc...In other words, the fundamentals of the game. It doesn't have to be every aspect every day, but perhaps on a rotating basis, maybe 10 minutes a day. Create a team philosophy, an approach towards becoming a fundamentally sound team. Positional players work on their swing daily, pitchers have a throwing routine, yet working to improve the rest of the skills at the major league level should be considered offensive?
 

Pablo's TB Lover

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 10, 2017
6,017
'They don't owe the fans an exact game strategy' and all that, but from a fan perspective there isn't exactly a rush to the ticket booth for consecutive bullpen games over the weekend. Maybe "we" need to adjust our expectations, but there was nothing better even 10 years ago than counting 1 through 5 and figuring out which starting pitcher was on the mound for our upcoming game. Having 5 starters at all times USED to be a bare minimum when stocking a roster. Ok that's enough complaining as I become my avatar...
 

jon abbey

Shanghai Warrior
Moderator
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
71,235
from a fan perspective there isn't exactly a rush to the ticket booth for consecutive bullpen games over the weekend.
Out of curiosity I checked, Fenway was 96-97 percent full for all three games of this series.

36,376
36,162
36,732
 

Pablo's TB Lover

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 10, 2017
6,017
Out of curiosity I checked, Fenway was 96-97 percent full for all three games of this series.

36,376
36,162
36,732
Fair, I guess August is probably the wrong time for this data since they could draw a 95% capacity fair weather crowd while 20 games under .500.

Edit: traditionally, April followed by September are the most variable months based on performance.
 

Tony Pena's Gas Cloud

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 12, 2019
375
Wrong about Kluber. See below (ERA+ of 85)

To be clear, neither of you are right or wrong but to act like your series of cherry picked stats (walks and QS) and moved goalposts (apparently the Sox can only sign pitchers to one year deals in your calculus ?) somehow ends the argument of whether signing an injury prone, old pitcher was prudent use of resources is insane and shows a lot of hubris
Not hubris at all. I can add a 3.57 FIP in '22 to "cherry picks" if you'd like. And nowhere did I say they could "only sign one year deals". You think a more "prudent use of resources" would have been making a Rodon-type splash?
I explained the logic behind the signing. I don't recall anyone complaining about it at the time. In fact, the person who bashed Bloom for signing Kluber actually commented in the original Kluber thread, so he had every opportunity to voice his dissention with the signing then. He didn't. So his bash is being made retroactively to fit his agenda rather than a belief he had from day one. That, my friend, is moving goalposts.
 
Last edited:

Tony Pena's Gas Cloud

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 12, 2019
375
The idea that Cora and his staff have to spend time teaching basic fundamentals to supposed major league level players is pretty offensive.
Perhaps you missed the part during today's broadcast when they discussed that the Blue Jays practiced baserunning during the pre-games? Seems to me that if a team has a glaring flaw it's up to the manager and coaches to address it. The Jays had no qualms about it.
 

Al Zarilla

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
59,414
San Andreas Fault
Perhaps you missed the part during today's broadcast when they discussed that the Blue Jays practiced baserunning during the pre-games? Seems to me that if a team has a glaring flaw it's up to the manager and coaches to address it. The Jays had no qualms about it.
I would have loved to have seen that. What did they practice: rundowns, pickoff plays, hitting fungoes to left, center and right and deciding whether to try to score or not? I hope Cora noted the the whole thing. No qualms indeed, if I made the millions these guys make, I'd practice running into the Green Monster. It's only made of tin, right?
 

Tony Pena's Gas Cloud

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 12, 2019
375
I would have loved to have seen that. What did they practice: rundowns, pickoff plays, hitting fungoes to left, center and right and deciding whether to try to score or not? I hope Cora noted the the whole thing. No qualms indeed, if I made the millions these guys make, I'd practice running into the Green Monster. It's only made of tin, right?
Per the announcers it was scoring from second base. I'm not sure why you're being snarky, I'm simply stating a fact.
 

twibnotes

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
20,381
Per the announcers it was scoring from second base. I'm not sure why you're being snarky, I'm simply stating a fact.
it was also mentioned on the radio broadcast that the rays’ infield practice is more intense than most - hard hit balls that cause the players to move.

the notion that the coaching staff can’t impact fundamentals seems ridiculous. Obviously different teams take different approaches, and some likely work better
 

Manuel Aristides

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 7, 2009
229
I'm on board with criticisms of the team's efforts and fundamentals. But people speculating about what Story needs to do could stand to get some perspective. There's simply no way you know better than him what he needs to be ready. And labeling the decision "unilateral" is pure speculation; were you on the conference call with Story, Bloom, the medical team, and whoever else may weigh in there? Of course not. I get that it's been a frustrating week but we don't get to start telling strangers what they need to do for their personal health and well-being just because the Blue Jays were in town.